Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies

From: Short-term outcomes and long-term quality of life of reconstruction methods after proximal gastrectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Authors

Country

Study period

Publication year

Design

Tumor location

Approach

Groups

Reconstruction techniques

Size of remnant stomach

Number of patients

Aburatani T, et al.

Japan

2005–2014

2017

RS

U/EGJ

LAPG

DTR/EG

Circular

-

19/22

Adachi Y, et al.

Japan

1992–1998

1999

RS

U

OPG

GT/JI

Circular

One-third

14/16

Chen X, et al.

China

2009–2010

2012

RS

EGJ

OPG

GT/EG

-

30–60%

35/41

Eom B, et al.

Korea

2013–2017

2021

RS

U

LPG

DTR/EG

Linear/ Hand- sewn

-

58/45

Hu L, et al.

China

2006–2019

2021

RS

U

OPG + LPG

JI/EG

-

-

43/39

Ichikawa D, et al.

Japan

1992–1999

2001

RS

U

-

JI/EG

-

-

13/13

Isobe T, et al.

Japan

1989–2008

2014

RS

U

-

EG/JI/JPI

-

-

66/23/12

Ji X, et al.

China

2014–2019

2021

RS

U/EGJ

OPG

DTR/EG

Circular

More than half

25/39

Li L, et al.

China

2000–2009

2011

RS

-

-

EG/JI/GT

Circular

-

50/26/44

Li Z, et al.

China

2015–2017

2019

RCT

EGJ

OPG

DTR/JI

-

-

98/103

Masuzawa T, et al.

Japan

1998–2005

2014

RS

U

-

JI/EG

-

-

32/49

Miyauchi W, et al.

Japan

2010–2018

2020

RS

U

LPG

DTR/EG

Linear/Circular

-

24/23

Nakamura M, et al.

Japan

1999–2011

2014

RS

U

-

EG/JI/JPI

Circular

Half

55/25/12

Nomura E, et al.

Japan

2012–2016

2019

RS

-

LPG

DTR/JI

Circular

Half

15/15

Shiraishi N, et al.

Japan

1993–1999

2002

RS

U

OPG

GT/JI

Circular

-

14/17

Takagawa R, et al.

Japan

2000–2008

2010

RCT

U

-

JI/JPI

Circular

-

19/19

Tokunaga M, et al.

Japan

1996–2005

2008

RS

-

-

JI/EG

Circular

-

40/36

Toyomasu Y, et al.

Japan

2000–2014

2016

RS

U

LAPG

GT/JI

Circular

One-third

84/40

Wang X, et al.

China

2018–2020

2021

RS

U

OPG + LPG + RPG

DTR/EG

-

-

89/83

Yasuda A, et al.

Japan

2001–2011

2015

RS

U

LAPG + OPG

GT/JI

Circular

-

25/21

Zeng C, et al.

China

2000–2012

2014

RS

U

-

JI/EG

-

-

28/40

Zhang B, et al.

China

2011–2011

2013

RS

U

OPG

JI/EG

-

-

30/30

Zhang Z, et al.

China

2010–2011

2013

RCT

U

-

JI/EG

Circular

-

41/41

Zhao Q, et al.

China

2004–2008

2015

RS

EGJ

OPG

JI/EG

Circular

-

266/252

Kumamoto, et al.

Japan

2011–2016

2021

RS

U

OPG

DFT/JI

Hand- sewn/Circular

-

14/20

Sakuramoto, et al.

Japan

2005–2008

2009

RS

U

LAPG

DTR/ EG

Linear

-

10/26

Seshimo, et al.

Japan

1999–2012

2013

RS

U

-

JI/EG

-

-

18/26

  1. RS retrospective study RCT randomized controlled trail U upper EGJ esophagogastric junction LAPG laparoscopic-assisted proximal gastrectomy OPG open proximal gastrectomy LPG laparoscopic proximal gastrectomy DTR double tract reconstruction EG esophagogastrostomy JI jejunal interposition GT gastric tube reconstruction JPI jejunal pouch interposition