Table 4 Patients’ characteristics comparative studies
Author | Age (I1/C2) years | Gender M: F (I1/C2) | ASA (I1/C2) | Indication for surgery Benign: malignant (I1/C2) | Types of surgery performed (I1/C2) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bednarski et al. [32] | 58.7/59.3 (mean) | 14: 16 | II: 0 / 2 III: 14/ 14 | 1: 13 / 1: 15 | Right colectomy: 8 / 8 Left colectomy: 3 / 1 LAR3: 3 / 7 |
Kiran et al. [28] | 55.2–58.3/60.2 (mean) | 40: 47 / 41: 47 | I-II: 51 / 47 III: 36 / 41 | Benign: 37 / 34 Malignancy/adenoma: 40 / 37 Other (not specified): 10 / 17 | Ileocolic resection: 14 / 14 Right colectomy: 17 / 25 Transverse colectomy: 4 / 2 Left colectomy: 4 / 5 Sigmoid colectomy: 35 / 25 LAR3: 10 / 15 Subtotal colectomy: 3 / 4 |
Lee et al. [12] | 60.2/56.5 (mean) | 22: 26 / 43: 30 | I: 4 / 4 II: 27 / 38 III: 17 / 31 | 19: 25 / 15: 47 Other (not specified): 3 / 3 | Right colectomy: 14 / 33 Left/sigmoid colectomy: 12 / 22 LAR3: 7 / 11 Stoma closure: 15 / 7 |
Popeskou et al. [33] | 67/70 (median) | 34: 17 / 369: 413 | I: 10 / 110 II: 35 / 482 III: 6 / 168 IV: 0 / 6 | 6: 45 / 192: 590 | Ileocolonic resection: 1 / 156 Right hemicolectomy: 29 / 328 Extended right hemicolectomy: 0 / 63 Left hemicolectomy: 1 / 31 Sigmoid colectomy: 1 / 55 High anterior rectal resection: 19 / 282 |
Tweed et al. [26] | 64.2/69.4 (mean) | 27: 24 / 33: 42 | I: 1 / 8 II: 40 / 67 | 0: 41 / 0: 75 | Left hemicolectomy: 3 / 6 Right hemicolectomy: 19 / 28 High anterior resection: 18 / 37 Transverse colectomy: 1 / 1 Total colectomy: 0 / 1 Subtotal colectomy: 0 / 2 |