Table 2 Characteristics included non-comparative studies, patient demographics, ERP versus ERAS, and outcomes
Author/year | Nr patients | Intervention | Primary LOS | Total LOS | Readmissions | Complications | Reoperation | Mortality | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
de Azevedo et al. [34]; 2021 | 664 | < 24 h ERP | 237 pt discharged < 24 h (35.7%) | NI1 | 16 (6.8%) of patients discharged < 24 h | NI1 | 2 of patients discharged < 24 h (0.8%) | No morality among early discharged patients | Causes readmission early discharged patients: 10 ileus, 3 AL2, 1 SSI3, 1 internal hernia, 1 incisional hernia |
Chasserant et al. [30]; 2016 | 40 | Outpatient colectomy protocol | 97.5% SDD4 (39 pt) | NI1 | 0 | 2.5% | 0 | 0% | NI1 |
Curfman et al. [27]; 2022 | 115 | SDD4 protocol | 100% SDD4 | NI1 | 0.9% | NI1 | 0 | 0 | NI1 |
Favuzza et al. [31]; 2013 | 100 | ERP with TAP5 block | 27% discharge POD1, 62% discharged < 48 h, median LOS 2 days | NI1 | 2% | 8% | NI1 | 0% | NI1 |
Lee et al. [17]; 2022 | 105 (site 1: 70/site 2: 35) | SDD4 ERP | Success rate SDD3: 80/63%, LOS 1 (both sites, median; days) | NI1 | 9/14% | 16/20% | NI1 | NI1 | 4 genitourinary compl., 4 other, 3 bleeding, 3 SSI3, 2 ileus, 2 AL2, 2 infections, 1 cardiopulmonary compl. |
Levy et al. [9]; 2009 | 10 | 23 h ERP | 0.95 (median; days), 100% discharged < 24 h | 0.95 (median; days) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0% | - |
Seux et al. [11]; 2022 | 177 | Ambulatory ERP | 14 (mean; hours) | NI1 | 9% | 14.7% | 8 (4.5%) | 0% | 7 AL2 fistula, 4 anastomotic haemorrhage, 1 ileocolic bleeding |
Studniarek et al. [29]; 2020 | 360 | ERP with one night hospital stay | 21.7% discharged < 24 h, LOS 3.4 (mean; days) | NI1 | 8.6% | 13.6% | 1 (0.3%) | 0.3% | CD6 I: 30 pt, CD6 II: 9, CD6 IIIa: 2, CD6 V: 1 |