Skip to main content

Table 3 Primary outcome measures in included studies

From: Radical prostatectomy versus external beam radiotherapy with androgen deprivation therapy for high-risk prostate cancer: a systematic review

Author (year)

Treatment

Outcome: HRQoL

Ciezki (2017) [25]

RP ± RT ± ADT

10 yr cumulative incidence of ≥ grade3 GU and GI toxicity: 16.4% and 1.0%

EBRT ± ADT

10 yr cumulative incidence of ≥ grade3 GU and GI toxicity: 8.1% and 4.6%

Hoffman (2020) [13]

RP

EPIC: EBRT + ADT vs RP at 3yrs (higher scores indicate a better function):

- Sexual function score: 9.1 (3.5–14.8) – MCID: 10–12

- Urinary incontinence score: 21.8 (17.1–26.6) – MCID: 6–9

- Urinary Irritative score: 1.1 (-1.6; 3.7) – MCID: 5–7

- Bowel function score: -1.6 (-4.3;1.2) – MCID: 4–6

- Hormone function score: -0.2 (-3.0; -2.6) – MCID: 4–6

SF-36: EBRT + ADT vs RP at 3yrs (higher scores indicate a better function):

- Physical Function score: -4.8 (-9.0; -0.7) – MCID: 7

- Emotional Wellbeing score: -1.7 (-4.4; 1.1) – MCID: 6

- Energy/Fatigue score: -3.4 (-6.7; -0.2) – MCID: 9

EBRT + ADT

see RP

Tward (2020) [23]

RP ± RT ± ADT

Difference from baseline at 24–42 months: SHIM (sexual dysfunction, lower is worse): -10

AUA-SS (urinary obstruction and irritation, higher is worse):-2.6

RFAS (bowel problems, higher is worse): 1.6

EBRT + ADT

Difference from baseline at 24–42 months: SHIM:-10.5, AUA-SS: -0.7; RFAS: 2.0

EBRT + BT + ADT

Difference from baseline at 24–42 months: SHIM:-7, AUA-SS: -1.4; RFAS: 1.7

  1. Abbreviations: ADT Androgen Deprivation Therapy, BT Brachytherapy, EPIC Expanded Prostate Cancer Index Composite, GI Gastrointestinal, GU Genitourinary, HRQoL Health related quality of life, MCID Minimal Clinically Important Difference, RFAS Rectal Function Assessment Scale, RP Radical Prostatectomy, RT Radiotherapy, SF-36 Short Form-36, SHIM) Sexual Health Inventory in Men