Skip to main content

Table 1 The principal characteristics and further details of eligible articles

From: The impact of anti-tumor approaches on the outcomes of cancer patients with COVID-19: a meta-analysis based on 52 cohorts incorporating 9231 participants

Author

Year

Study design

Region

Number of patient

Male

Median age (IQR) (years)

Diagnosis method for COVID-19

Cancer type

Comparison group

Kuderer NM [6]

2020

Retro-prospective

multi-national

928

468

66 (57–76)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Lee LYW [19]

2020

Prospective

UK

800

449

69 (59–76)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Zhang L [14]

2020

Retrospective

China

28

17

65 (56–70)

RT-PCR

solid tumor

cancer patients with no treatment

Stroppa EM [20]

2020

Retrospective

Italy

25

20

71 (mean) (50–84)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Yang K [7]

2020

Retrospective

China

205

96

63 (56–70)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Zhang H [21]

2020

Retrospective

China

107

60

66 (36–98)

RT-PCR and/or radiology

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Robilotti EV [22]

2020

Retrospective

USA

423

212

NA

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Yarza R [23]

2020

Prospective

Spain

63

34

NA

RT-PCR and/or radiology

solid tumor

cancer patients treated other options

Li Q [24]

2020

Retrospective

China

59

31

63 (54–70)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Jee J [25]

2020

Retrospective

USA

309

159

NA

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Sanchez-Pina JM [26]

2020

Retrospective

Spain

39

23

64 (mean)

RT-PCR

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Pinato DJ [15]

2020

Retrospective

multi-national

890

503

68 (mean)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Assaad S [27]

2020

Retrospective

France

55

26

64 (mean)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Garassino MC [28]

2020

Retrospective

multi-national

200

141

68 (61–75)

RT-PCR

Thoracic Cancer

cancer patients with no treatment

Liang WH [29]

2020

Retrospective

China

18

12

60 (47–87)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Ma J [30]

2020

Retrospective

China

37

20

62 (IQR: 59–70)

RT-PCR and/or antibody test

solid tumor

cancer patients with no treatment

Mehta V [11]

2020

Retrospective

USA

218

127

69 (10–92)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Yu J [31]

2020

Retrospective

China

12

10

66 (48–78)

RT-PCR and/or CT

solid tumor

cancer patients with no active antitumor treatment

Tian J [4]

2020

Retrospective

China

232

119

64 (58–69)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with surgery

Fox TA [32]

2020

Retrospective

UK

55

38

63 (23–88)

RT-PCR, CT, and clinical features

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Booth S [33]

2020

Prospective

UK

66

41

73 (IQR: 63–81)

RT-PCR, radiological, and clinical features

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Cattaneo C [34]

2020

Retrospective

Italy

102

66

68 (mean)

RT-PCR

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Lara OD [35]

2020

Retrospective

USA

121

NA

64 (IQR: 51–73)

RT-PCR and CT

gynecologic cancer

cancer patients with no treatment

Liu C [36]

2020

Retrospective

China

216

113

63 (IQR: 57–70)

RT-PCR

solid tumor

cancer patients with no treatment

Luo J [37]

2020

Retrospective

USA

102

49

68 (IQR: 61–75)

RT-PCR

lung cancer

cancer patients with no treatment

Mato AR [38]

2020

Retrospective

multi-national

198

125

63 (35–92)

RT-PCR

chronic lymphocytic leukemia

cancer patients with no treatment

Rogado J [39]

2020

Retrospective

Spain

45

30

71 (34–90)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Russell B [40]

2020

Retro-prospective

UK

156

90

65 (mean)

RT-PCR

solid tumor

cancer patients with no treatment

Scarfò L [41]

2020

Retrospective

multi-national

190

126

72 (48–94)

RT-PCR

chronic lymphocytic leukemia

cancer patients with no treatment

Vuagnat P [42]

2020

Retrospective

France

58

NA

58 (IQR:48–68)

RT-PCR and/or CT

breast cancer

cancer patients with no treatment

Wang BO [43]

2020

Retrospective

USA

58

30

67

RT-PCR

multiple myeloma

cancer patients with no treatment

Wang J [44]

2020

Retrospective

China

283

141

63 (IQR: 55–70)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Gonzalez-cao M [45]

2020

Retrospective

Spain

50

27

69 (6–94)

clinical or RT-PCR

melanoma

cancer patients with no treatment

De Melo AC [46]

2020

Retrospective

Brazil

181

71

55 (2–88)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no active antitumor treatment

Albiges L [47]

2020

Retrospective

France

178

76

61 (52–71)

RT-PCR and/or CT

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Martínez-López J [48]

2020

Retrospective

Spain

167

95

71 (IQR: 62–78)

RT-PCR

multiple myeloma (MM)

cancer patients with no treatment

Martín-Moro F [49]

2020

Retrospective

Spain

34

19

72.5 (35–94)

RT-PCR and/or CT

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Lattenist R [50]

2021

Retrospective

Belgium

13

10

70 (IQR: 59–79)

RT-PCR and/or CT

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Nakamura S [51]

2020

Retrospective

Japan

32

22

74.5 (24–90)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Rogiers A [52]

2021

Retrospective

multi-national

110

72

63 (27–86)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Glenthøj A [16]

2021

Prospective

Denmark

66

40

66.7 (25–91)

 

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Song C [17]

2020

Retrospective

China

223

116

63 (56–71)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with discontinous treatment

Lunski MJ [18]

2020

Retrospective

USA

312

142

NA

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Nie L [53]

2020

Retrospective

China

45

31

66 (58–74)

RT-PCR

lung cancer

cancer patients with no treatment

Larfors G [54]

2020

Retrospective

Sweden

NA

NA

NA

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

H€ollein A [55]

2020

Retrospective

Germany

17

8

73 (27–82)

RT-PCR

non-specific

cancer patients with no treatment

Garnett C [56]

2020

Retrospective

UK

32

21

72.5 (46–96)

RT-PCR

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Hanna GJ [57]

2020

Retrospective

USA

32

20

70 (38–91)

RT-PCR

head and neck cancer

cancer patients with no treatment

Lie’vre A [58]

2020

Retro-prospective

France

1289

795

67 (19–100)

RT-PCR

solid tumor

cancer patients with no treatment

Smith M [59]

2020

Retrospective

USA

86

NA

69 (mean)

RT-PCR

solid tumor

cancer patients with no treatment

Wu YG [60]

2020

Retrospective

China

14

9

37 (14–68)

RT-PCR

hematological malignancies

cancer patients with no treatment

Yang F [12]

2020

Retrospective

China

52

28

63 (34–98)

RT-PCR

solid tumor

cancer patients with no treatment

Author

Number of the control

Anti-tumor therapy

Chemotherapy

Immunotherapy

Targeted therapy

Endocrine therapy

Surgery

Radiotherapy

Outcome

Required mechanical ventilation

Severe COVID-19

Death

Kuderer NM [6]

553

366

160

38

75

85

32

12

death

116

242

121

Lee LYW [19]

272

528

281

44

72

64

29

76

death

NA

360

226

Zhang L [14]

22

6

3

1

2

NA

NA

1

sever COVID-19

10

15

8

Stroppa EM [20]

13

12

8

4

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

9

Yang K [7]

128

54

31

4

12

NA

4

9

death

32

52

40

Zhang H [21]

70

37

NA

6

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

56

23

Robilotti EV [22]

NA

NA

191

31

NA

NA

31

NA

sever COVID-19

40

85

51

Yarza R [23]

NA

NA

36

8

7

10

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

24

16

Li Q [24]

43

16

12

NA

6

NA

1

1

death

27

35

16

Jee J [25]

43

170

102

18

49

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19

NA

120

31

Sanchez-Pina JM [26]

15

24

4

NA

5

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

18

NA

Pinato DJ [15]

403

479

206

56

93

92

NA

33

sever COVID-19; death

97

565

299

Assaad S [27]

26

29

16

3

14

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

30

Garassino MC [28]

58

142

48

34

28

NA

NA

NA

death

9

NA

66

Liang WH [29]

14

4

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19

NA

9

NA

Ma J [30]

24

13

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19

NA

20

5

Mehta V [11]

NA

NA

42

5

NA

NA

NA

49

death

45

NA

61

Yu J [31]

5

7

5

2

1

NA

1

4

sever COVID-19; death

NA

3

3

Tian J [4]

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

119

NA

sever COVID-19

NA

148

NA

Fox TA [32]

NA

NA

29

25

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

25

19

Booth S [33]

29

37

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

34

Cattaneo C [34]

43

59

20

28

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

40

Lara OD [35]

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

20

NA

Liu C [36]

138

78

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

37

Luo J [37]

48

54

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

18

NA

25

Mato AR [38]

79

119

51

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

53

NA

66

Rogado J [39]

15

30

19

1

2

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

29

19

Russell B [40]

18

81

45

7

5

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

28

34

Scarfò L [41]

73

116

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

151

56

Vuagnat P [42]

NA

NA

29

NA

19

19

3

36

sever COVID-19

NA

NA

4

Wang BO [43]

11

47

NA

NA

28

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

14

Wang J [44]

188

95

46

NA

12

NA

23

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

NA

50

Gonzalez-cao M [45]

12

38

NA

22

16

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

34

13

De Melo AC [46]

16

165

63

NA

NA

20

12

10

death

34

NA

60

Albiges L [47]

61

117

66

19

30

16

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

47

31

Martínez-López J [48]

NA

NA

83

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

15

141

56

Martín-Moro F [49]

NA

19

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

4

17

11

Lattenist R [50]

6

7

3

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

6

Nakamura S [51]

19

13

10

3

NA

4

13

NA

death

3

NA

11

Rogiers A [52]

NA

NA

25

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

35

18

Glenthøj A [16]

10

9

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19

NA

33

NA

Song C [17]

19

204

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19

NA

159

NA

Lunski MJ [18]

256

56

12

4

9

44

5

2

death

NA

NA

66

Nie L [53]

34

11

4

4

NA

NA

3

NA

death

3

23

11

Larfors G [54]

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19; death

NA

NA

NA

H€ollein A [55]

2

15

14

1

2

NA

NA

1

death

3

NA

6

Garnett C [56]

10

22

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

18

Hanna GJ [57]

26

6

3

1

0

NA

4

1

death

NA

NA

NA

Lie’vre A [58]

NA

NA

577

110

181

57

56

133

death

49

NA

370

Smith M [59]

47

39

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

sever COVID-19

NA

29

NA

Wu YG [60]

NA

NA

7

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

death

NA

NA

6

Yang F [12]

NA

NA

6

1

NA

NA

2

NA

sever COVID-19

NA

19

11

  1. Abbreviations: ICIs Immune checkpoint inhibitors, RT-PCR Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction, NA Not available, ICU Intensive Care Unit