Parameters | 3D planning group | 2D planning group | P value |
---|---|---|---|
Age (years) | 43.8±8.8(28-57) | 43.2±7.9(31-60) | 0.766 |
Mean max diameter (cm) | 7.5±1.7(5-12.5) | 7.2±1.3(5.1-10.8) | 0.451 |
Volume of tumor (ml) | 148.2±89.1 (26.8-301.1) | 128.4±71.4(39.8-375.8) | 0.352 |
Aspiration blood volume (ml) | 108.4±84.9 (14-284) | 108.5±75.9(21-359) | 0.996 |
Ablation power (J) | 87407.2.9±50387.0(3000-226400) | 117775.8±46245.6(6000-200800) | 0.021* |
Ablation time (s) | 1152.0±403.9(600-1890) | 1379.7±375.8(810-2230) | 0.031* |
Antenna insertion | 4.8±1.9(2-9) | 4.1±1.2(2-6) | 0.068 |
Complete ablation rate (%) | 97.7±2.4(93-100) | 94.5±3.7(90-100) | 0.0004* |
Reduction rate of volume (%) | 53.4±7.5(43.5-76.0) | 51.1±9.0(35.2-76.7) | 0.299 |
Case of hemoglobinuria (No.) | 8/17 | 19/14 | 0.047* |
ALT-pre(U/L) | 20.3±15.2(6.9-84.0) | 24.7±18.0(9.0-107.5) | 0.330 |
AST-pre(U/L) | 19.2±6.5(11.8-38.6) | 18.9±7.4(10.8-34.6) | 0.872 |
ALP-pre(U/L) | 63.0±18.1(40.4-98.8) | 65.2±15.4(39.8-94.3) | 0.618 |
GGT-pre(U/L) | 23.5±16.6(8.6-38.1) | 24.8±11.0(6.7-48.2) | 0.709 |
Cre-pre(umol/L) | 63.0±8.9 (49.9-78.7) | 57.2±15.1(37.6-85.9) | 0.092 |
BUN-pre(mmol/L) | 4.7±1.2(2.8-7.8) | 4.2±1.0(2.6-6.4) | 0.055 |
STB-pre (U/L) | 12.3±3.6(6.4-20.1) | 12.4±5.3(5.4-26.3) | 0.923 |
DBIL-pre (U/L) | 4.5±1.3(2.3-7.5) | 5.2±1.5(2.9-7.9) | 0.070 |
ALT-post (U/L) | 126.7±56.4(37.0-224.1) | 210.9±96.2(94.8-345.0) | 0.0002* |
AST-post (U/L) | 141.0±60.8(40.2-237.0) | 211.4±90.0(32-294.5) | 0.001* |
ALP-post(U/L) | 57.3±17.6(34.6-79.4) | 80.8±41.9(36.4-178.0) | 0.010* |
GGT-post(U/L) | 26.5±17.6(9.4-64.2) | 37.8±19.1(8.8-92.8) | 0.060 |
Cre-post(umol/L) | 66.6±16.6(51.3-117.0) | 84.5±39.6(40.8-204.0) | 0.037* |
BUN-post(mmol/L) | 4.4±2.6(1.3-13.8) | 6.6±5.3(2.4-18.1) | 0.061 |
STB-post (U/L) | 28.0±14.4(8.7-70.7) | 32.4±14.2(3.8-74.1) | 0.252 |
DBIL-post (U/L) | 8.4±4.6 (1.2-17.7) | 10.6±10.0(3.4-49.4) | 0.428 |