Skip to main content

Table 2 Mean survival (months) estimates from studies of patients with mixed histologies

From: Comparative survival benefit of currently licensed second or third line treatments for epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) and anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) negative advanced or metastatic non-small cell lung cancer: a systematic review and secondary analysis of trials

TRIAL

Outcome

Intervention (n)

Control (n)

Intervention minus control

REVEL

 

Ram + Doc (628)

Plac + Doc (625)

 

 RMS [95% CI]

to 19 mos

11.00 [10.47–11.52]

10.01 [9.48–10.55]

0.99 [0.24–1.73]

 Mean total OS

R_mSext

15.02

14.31

0.71

 Mean total OS

Weibull [95% CI]

14.87 [13.40–16.57]

12.99 [11.71–14.46]

1.88 [−0.22–3.98]

 Mean total OS

Weibull formula

14.87

12.98

1.89

LUME LUNG-1

 

Nin + Doc (655)

Plac + Doc (659)

 

 RMS [95% CI]

to 19 mos

10.85 [10.35–11.36]

10.38 [9.88–10.87]

0.48 [−0.23–1.18]

 Mean total OS

R_mSext

14.38

13.57

0.82

 Mean total OS

Weibull [95% CI]

14.08 [12.97–15.31]

13.21 [12.17–14.35]

0.87 [− 0.73–2.47]

 Mean total OS

Weibull formula

14.08

13.20

0.88

POPLAR

 

Atezolizumab (144)

Docetaxel (143)

 

 RMS [95% CI]

to 19 mos

11.84 [10.71–12.97]

10.39 [9.33–11.46]

1.45 [−0.11–3.00]

 Mean total OS

R_mSext

20.76

13.00

7.76

 Mean total OS

Weibull [95% CI]

17.89 [13.69–24.31]

12.15 [10.02–15.05]

5.74 [−0.135–11.61]

 Mean total OS

Weibull formula

17.93

12.15

5.78

OAK

 

Atezolizumab (425)

Docetaxel (425)

 

 RMS [95% CI]

to 19 mos

12.31 [11.65–12.96]

10.68 [10.03–11.33]

1.62 [0.70–2.55]

 Mean total OS

R_mSext

20.76

12.24

8.52

 Mean total OS

Weibull [95% CI]

18.93 [16.54–21.81]

13.59 [12.11–15.32]

5.34 [2.25–8.43]

 Mean total OS

Weibull formula

18.98

13.34

5.64

KEYNOTE-010

 

Pembrolizumab (344)

Docetaxel (343)

 

 RMS [95% CI]

to 19 mos

11.40 [10.62–12.19]

9.82 [9.05–10.59]

1.58 [0.48–2.68]

 Mean total OS

R_mSext

20.64

12.74

7.89

 Mean total OS

Weibull [95% CI]

16.14 [13.51–19.68]

11.10 [9.68–12.88]

5.04 [1.57–8.52]

 Mean total OS

Weibull formula

16.43

10.42

6.01

TAILOR

 

Erlotinib (109)

Docetaxel (110)

 

 RMS [95% CI]

to 19 mos

7.66 [6.15–8.81]

9.30 [8.02–10.57]

−1.64 [−3.36–0.08]

 Mean total OS

R_mSext

8.90

11.16

−2.26

 Mean total OS

Weibull [95% CI]

8.67 [6.99–10.86]

11.11 [8.80–14.25]

− 2.44 [−5.78–0.90]

 Mean total OS

Weibull formula

8.67

11.10

−2.43

HORG

 

Erlotinib (166)

Pemetrexed (166)

 

 RMS [95% CI]

to 19 mos

10.18 [9.10–11.26]

9.85 [8.73–10.97]

0.33 [− 1.23–1.88]

 Mean total OS

R_mSext

15.33

14.42

0.91

 Mean total OS

Weibull [95% CI]

15.02 [11.94–18.94]

13.86 [11.21–17.35]

1.16 [−3.5–5.82]

 Mean total OS

Weibull formula

15.12

13.86

1.25

Hanna

 

Pemetrexed (283)

Docetaxel (288)

 

 RMS [95% CI]

to 19 mos

8.80 [8.10–9.50]

8.70 [7.96–9.44]

0.10 [−0.92–1.12]

 Mean total OS

R_mSext

9.64

8.83

0.81

 Mean total OS

Weibull [95% CI]

9.34 [8.30–10.57]

9.35 [8.20–10.74]

−0.01 [−1.71–1.69]

 Mean total OS

Weibull formula

9.34

9.34

−0.01

  1. OS overall survival, RMS restricted mean survival; R_mSext restricted mean survival exponentially extended from the end of the KM plot, Mean total OS Weibull formula mean OS estimated from Weibull model parameters using the formula published by Davies et al. [13]