Skip to main content

Table 3 Antimicrotubule trials: PSA and tumor response.

From: Non-hormonal systemic therapy in men with hormone-refractory prostate cancer and metastases: a systematic review from the Cancer Care Ontario Program in Evidence-based Care's Genitourinary Cancer Disease Site Group

Trial

Treatment arms

PSA response*

Tumor response

  

N

Response rate %

Statistical comparison

N

Objective response rate %

Statistical comparison

Tannock, 2004 [64]

docetaxel q 3 wks prednisone

291

45

p < 0.001

141

12

p = 0.1

 

docetaxel q wk prednisone

291

48

p < 0.001

134

8

p = 0.6

 

Mitoxantrone prednisone

300

32

NA

137

7

NA

Petrylak, 2004 [63]

Docetaxel EMP

309

50

p < 0.001

103

17

p < 0.30

 

Mitoxantrone prednisone

303

27

 

93

11

 

Abratt, 2004 [62]

Vinorelbine hydrocortisone ± AGM

206

30.1

p < 0.01

68

5.9(PR)

NR

 

hydrocortisone ± AGM

208

19.2

 

74

0

 

Berry, 2001 [84]

Paclitaxel EMP

166

48

p < 0.01

NR

 

Paclitaxel

 

25

    

Hudes, 1999 [61]

vinblastine EMP

87

25.2

p < 0.0001

30

20 (PR)

p = 0.13

 

Vinblastine

94

3.2

 

33

6 (PR)

 

Iversen, 1997 [65]

EMP

43

37.2

p = 0.001

NR

 

Placebo

51

2.0

    

Johansson, 1991 [66]

EMP

NR

  

NR

 

MPA

      

De Kernion, 1988 [67]

EMP

NR

  

102

0

p = NS

 

Flutamide

   

101

1.0 (PR)

 

Murphy, 1979 [68]

EMP prednimustine

NR

  

54

1.9 (PR)

p = NS

 

prednimustine

   

62

0

 
  1. *PSA response was defined as = 50 decrease in PSA compared with baseline.
  2. Abbreviations: AGM – aminoglutethimide; EMP – estramustine phosphate; MPA – medroxyprogesterone acetate; N – number; NA – not applicable; NR – not reported; NS – non-significant; PR – partial response; PSA – prostate-specific-antigen; q – every; wk(s) – week(s).