Study | n | Population | Treatments | Follow-up | Outcomes | Key limitations compared with the CATCH study design |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CLOT [28] | 672 | Acute symptomatic proximal DVT and/or PE | Dalteparin qd (5–7 days) + warfarin* (6 months) | 6 months | Recurrent VTE (primary) 15.8% (W), 8.0% (D); P = 0.002 | Full-dose dalteparin not maintained for entire 6-month treatment period |
 |  |  | Dalteparin qd (6 months)†|  | Major bleeding 4% (W), 6.0% (D); P = 0.27 | No outcomes for PTS, HRQoL, predictors of recurrence, and healthcare resource utilisation |
Main-LITE‡[27] | 200 | Proximal DVT | UFH + warfarin (6 days) then warfarin (3 months) | 3 months and 12 months | Recurrent VTE (primary) 3 months: 10.0% (W), 6.0% (T) 12 months: 16.0% (W), 7.0% (T); P = 0.044 | Duration of randomised treatment only 3 months |
 |  |  | Tinzaparin qd (3 months) |  | Major bleeding 3 months: 7.0% (W), 7.0% (T) | Modest sample size with limited statistical power |
CANTHANOX [29] | 146 | DVT and/or PE | Enoxaparin qd (initial) + warfarin (3 months) | 3 months | Treatment failure § (primary) 21.1% (W), 10.5% (E); P = 0.09 | Composite primary endpoint (recurrent VTE and major bleeding) |
 |  |  | Enoxaparin qd (3 months) |  | Major bleeding 16.0% (W), 7.0% (E); P = 0.09 | Duration of randomised treatment only 3 months Small study with limited statistical power Trial stopped early because of slow recruitment |
ONCENOX [26] | 122 | Acute symptomatic VTE | Enoxaparin LD bid (5 days) + warfarin (6 months) | 6 months | Recurrent VTE (secondary) 10.0% (W), 6.9% (LD), 6.3% (HD) | Recurrent VTE was only a secondary objective (study did not meet its primary objective, which was to recruit the necessary number of patients within a 12-month time frame) Small study with limited statistical power |
 |  |  | Enoxaparin LD bid (5 days) then LD qd (6 months) |  |  |  |
 |  |  | Enoxaparin LD bid (5 days) then HD qd (6 months) |  | Major bleeding 2.9% (W), 6.5% (LD), 11.1% (HD) |  |