Survival after surgery among patients with cholangiocarcinoma in Northeast Thailand according to anatomical and morphological classification

Background Cholangiocarcinoma (CCA) has been categorized based on tumor location as intrahepatic (ICCA), perihilar (PCCA) or distal (DCCA), and based on the morphology of the tumor of the bile duct as mass forming (MF), periductal infiltrating (PI) or intraductal (ID). To date, there is limited evidence available regarding the survival of CCA among these different anatomical and morphological classifications. This study aimed to evaluate the survival rate and median survival time after curative surgery among CCA patients according to their anatomical and morphological classifications, and to determine the association between these classifications and survival. Methods This study included CCA patients who underwent curative surgery from the Cholangiocarcinoma Screening and Care Program (CASCAP), Northeast Thailand. The anatomical and morphological classifications were based on pathological findings after surgery. Survival rates of CCA and median survival time since the date of CCA surgery and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated. Multiple cox regression was performed to evaluate factors associated with survival which were quantified by hazard ratios (HR) and their 95% CIs. Results Of the 746 CCA patients, 514 had died at the completion of the study which constituted 15,643.6 person-months of data recordings. The incidence rate was 3.3 per 100 patients per month (95% CI: 3.0–3.6), with median survival time of 17.8 months (95% CI: 15.4–20.2), and 5-year survival rate of 24.6% (95% CI: 20.7–28.6). The longest median survival time was 21.8 months (95% CI: 16.3–27.3) while the highest 5-year survival rate of 34.8% (95% CI: 23.8–46.0) occurred in the DCCA group. A combination of anatomical and morphological classifications, PCCA+ID, was associated with the longest median survival time of 40.5 months (95% CI: 17.9–63.0) and the highest 5-year survival rate of 42.6% (95% CI: 25.4–58.9). The ICCA+MF combination was associated with survival (adjusted HR: 1.45; 95% CI: 1.01–2.09; P = 0.013) compared to ICCA+ID patients. Conclusions Among patients receiving surgical treatment, those with PCCA+ID had the highest 5-year survival rate, which was higher than in groups classified by only anatomical characteristics. Additionally, the patients with ICCA+MF tended to have unfavorable surgical outcomes. Showed the highest survival association. Therefore, further investigations into CCA imaging should focus on patients with a combination of anatomical and morphological classifications. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12885-021-08247-z.


(Continued from previous page)
Conclusions: Among patients receiving surgical treatment, those with PCCA+ID had the highest 5-year survival rate, which was higher than in groups classified by only anatomical characteristics. Additionally, the patients with ICCA+MF tended to have unfavorable surgical outcomes. Showed the highest survival association. Therefore, further investigations into CCA imaging should focus on patients with a combination of anatomical and morphological classifications.
Keywords: Cholangiocarcinoma, Anatomical, Morphological, Classification, Survival, CASCAP Background Cholangiocarcinoma (CCA) is the most common primary malignancy of the biliary tract [1]. CCA is relatively rare worldwide, but very high incidence rates have been reported in East and Southeast Asia, this is especially the case in Thailand [2], which has an estimated 6 million people infected with the liver fluke, Opisthorchis viverrini which is the major risk for developing CCA in this area [3]. In Thailand, CCA incidence has been recorded as being up to 87.7 per 100,000 in males and 36.3 per 100,000 in females [4]. It is the most common primary liver cancer in the northeast of Thailand where it has its highest incidence worldwide [5,6], and it is also one of the major causes of death. In comparison, the 2010-2012 age-standardized incidence rate of CCA worldwide was 53.4 per 100,000 population in males and 18.5 in females [7].
To address these on-going, serious health problems, a series of projects have been implemented to improve screening for CCA in high-risk populations. The first project was a screening program performed in Ban Luang District, Nan Province, Northern Thailand which found that the detection of early-stage CCA by ultrasonography (US) resulted in an improved clinical outcome [8]. Another program that was introduced was the Cholangiocarcinoma Screening and Care Program (CASCAP) which continues to screen high risk populations in high incidence areas in order to detect patients in with early stage CCA. A recent study from CASCAP showed that US screening was an effective tool for detecting earlystage CCA [9].
CCA has been classified based on the anatomic location of the bile duct tumor which is categorized as intrahepatic CCA (ICCA), perihilar CCA (PCCA) or distal CCA (DCCA) [10]. ICCA is the second-most common primary liver cancer; its incidence having increased by 22% between 1979 and 2004 [1]. The incidence of extrahepatic CCA increased from 2001 to 2007, coinciding with the 2001 implementation of a new version of the International Classification of Diseases for Oncology. Reanalysis of previous registries indicated that PCCA is often misclassified as ICCA, thus, the increase in ICCA reported by many registries could result from an increase in PCCA [11]. Previous studies have reported the survival of patients with ICCA after surgery in Thailand where the cumulative 1, 3, and 5-year survival rates were 52.1, 21.7, and 11.2%, respectively. The median duration of survival after resection was 12.4 months [12]. In comparison, survival of patients after resection of PCCA in the United States and Western Europe, had a median overall survival of 19 months and an estimated 1, 3 and 5-year survival of 69, 27 and 13%, respectively [13]. Conditional survival for patients with unresectable PCCA in the Netherlands between 2002 and 2012 had overall survival of 42% at 1-year and 6% at 3-year [14]. The survival of resected and unresected DCCA patients in the Netherlands between 2009 and 2016, had a median overall survival of 10.4 months across all stages; 21.9 months for resected, 6.7 months for unresected nonmetastatic, and 3.6 months for metastatic DCCA with the P was < 0.001 [15]. In 2019, there was a study performed in 11, 710 CCA patients from Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Cancer Registries (SEER) compared survival for ICCA, PCCA, and DCCA and found that 5-year overall survival was highest in ICCA (16.7%) followed by PCCA (16.4%) and DCCA (5.7%) [16].
In addition, CCA can be classified into mass-forming (MF), periductal-infiltrating (PI) and intraductal (ID) [17]. Previous studies have found a relationship between tumor location and tumor morphology in CCA patients. One study based on the survival analyses of four groups of ICCA according to tumor morphology: ID, PI, MF and PI plus MF, found that overall survival at 1, 5, and 10 years was 50, 36, and 36%, respectively. Moreover, this study also found a poor outcome in the case of MF with PI with the stage of CCA of IV-A [18].
Importantly, the very high mortality of CCA patients was directly related to difficulties in diagnosing the disease at an early stage when surgical cure is possible [19]. CCA is very difficult to detect and diagnose, and has a very poor prognosis with a 5-year survival rate of less than 5% [20]. Most CCA patients come to a physician at a late stage of the disease, as the tumors are clinically silent in the early stages [21,22]. However, there is limited evidence available regarding the survival rate of patients with different anatomical and morphological characteristics of CCA from the median time/date of surgery until patient death. Furthermore, there is limited evidence regarding those factors that are associated with the survival of CCA patients in different anatomical and morphological classifications.
Therefore, our study aimed to evaluate the survival rate and median survival time after surgery among patients with CCA according to anatomical and morphological classification and to determine whether there was an association of anatomical and morphological classification with survival after surgery in the northeast of Thailand.

Design overview
This study uses a prospective design, monitoring CCA patients who were diagnosed by biopsy and subsequently underwent resection for CCA until their final stage of life. The data from the Cholangiocarcinoma Screening and Care Program (CASCAP), northeast Thailand, were analyzed to evaluate the survival rate, median survival time, and factors that are associated with the survival of patients with different CCA anatomical and morphological classifications. All participants were from both screening and walk-in groups enrolled in the CASCAP database between 2013 and 2019. The screening group were participants who underwent routine ultrasonography screening for CCA but showed no symptoms that could be related to CCA. The walk-in group were participants presenting at the hospital with clinical symptoms suggestive of CCA as a possible cause. Both screening and walk-in groups were diagnosed for suspected CCA. Patients with the pre-operative findings that indicated a potential to be cured by surgical treatment such as having no distance metastasis or appearing to be resectable were provided a curative-intent operation. Patients in this category are definitely early stage (stage 0, I, and II) and are included in the study. We did not include patients with late stage (stages III and IV). The actual staging in our study was based on the findings after completion of the operation where the clinical and/or pathological characteristics can be correctly determined. Data on histological findings were based on the standard protocol of the tertiary hospital at Khon Kaen University, Thailand. The CCA patients with an unspecified anatomical classification and/or unknown stage of CCA, and/or the date of CCA diagnosis being incomplete were excluded from further analyses. This resulted in a total of 746 CCA cases which were included in the study following the sampling technique shown in Fig. 1.

Primary outcomes and study factors
The primary outcome for this study was the elapsed time (number of months) from the date of surgery for CCA (begin date) to the date of death or last follow-up (end date). The median follow-up period was 17.2 months with a total of five-year follow-up period. The factors of interest were the anatomical and morphological classifications which were categorized into 11 groups, namely, ICCA+MF (ICM), ICCA+PI (ICP), ICCA+ID (ICI), ICCA+Mix morphology (ICMIX), PCCA+MF (PCM), PCCA+PI (PCP), PCCA+ID (PCI), PCCA+Mix morphology (PCMIX), DCCA+MF (DCM), DCCA+PI (DCP), and DCCA+ID (DCI). The other factors included gender, age at enrolment, education levels, occupation, history of O. viverrini infection, history of praziquantel treatment, and stage of CCA. The CCA staging defined as early and late stage which early stage refers to stage 0, I, II, and late stage refers to stage III and IV according to the 7th edition AJCC staging [23,24].

Statistical analyses
The baseline characteristics of CCA patients were described using frequency and percentage for categorical data stratified by the anatomical and morphological classification of CCA. The mean, standard deviation (SD), median, and minimum and maximum range for continuous data were recorded.
The CCA incidence rate per 100 person-months since surgery with CCA and its 95% confidence interval (CI) were calculated based on Poisson distribution assumptions. The survival rate and median survival time since the date of surgery with CCA until death by CCA and its 95% CI were estimated using Kaplan-Meier methods. The association between the anatomical and morphological classification and CCA survival adjusted for other factors was quantified by adjusted hazard ratio (HR) and its 95% CI using multiple cox regression analysis. A Pvalue of less than 0.05 was considered to be significant. All analyses were performed using STATA version 15 (StataCorp, College Station, TX).

Results
A total of 746 CCA patients were included in the analysis with a mean age of 61.1 ± 8.5 years, ranging from 34 to 84 years, more than half (54.6%) were > 60 years old (Table 1). Around two-thirds were male and were in late stage of CCA (63.9 and 65.3%, respectively). According to the combination of anatomical and morphological classifications, the largest group, 31.9% (238/746), of patients were in the ICM group followed by 20.5% (153/ 746) of patients in the PCP group. The DCI group contained the lowest percentage of patients at 1.9% (14/ 746).

Survival analysis
Of a total of 746 CCA patients, constituting of 15,643.6 person-months of observations, 514 patients died after surgery. The overall incidence rate was 3.3 per 100 patients per month (95% CI: 3.0-3.6). According to the combination of anatomical and morphological classifications, the highest incidence rate was 4.7 per 100 patients per month (95% CI: 3.6-6.3) found in the PCM group, followed by patients with ICM with 4.1 per 100 patients per month (95% CI: 3.6-4.8), and for the PCP group 3.8 per 100 patients per month (95% CI: 3.2-4.6) ( Table 2). The overall median survival time after surgery was 17.8 months (95% CI: 15.4-20.2). According to the anatomical classification, the median survival was statistically not significantly different with a log-rank test P = 0.433 (Fig. 2). According to the combination of anatomical and morphological classifications, the median survival time for CCA patients after surgery was highly statistically significantly different across groups with a log-rank test P < 0.001. The patients with PCI had the longest median survival time (40.5 months; 95% CI: 17.9-63.0), whereas the shortest was found in patients with ICM (12.4 months; 95% CI: 10.2-14.6) (Fig. 3).

Bivariate and multivariable survival analysis
Bivariate results following cox regression analyses, according to the anatomical classification, showed no significant associations for patients in the PCCA and DCCA groups. After controlling for the effect of CCA staging, gender, age, history of O. viverrini infection and other factors, multivariable analyses showed a significant association with survival in patients with DCCA (HR: 0.67; 95% CI: 0.49-0.91) compared to the ICCA group (Table 3). According to the combination of anatomical and morphological classifications for CCA, bivariate results showed significant associations for patients in the ICM, PCM, and PCP groups. After controlling for the effect of CCA staging, gender, age, history of O. viverrini infection and other factors, multivariable analyses showed a significant association with survival in patients with ICM (HR: 1.45; 95% CI: 1.01-2.09) compared to the ICI group (Table 4).

Discussion
Cholangiocarcinoma is the most common primary malignancy of the biliary tract [1], with very high incidence rates reported in East and Southeast Asia, especially in Thailand [2]. The incidence of CCA has been reported to be as high as 87.7 per 100,000 in males and 36.3 per 100,000 in females [4].
Our study analyzed the pathological characteristics of CCA depending on its anatomical location (ICCA, PCCA, and DCCA) and morphological characteristics (MF, PI, ID) in order to evaluate the survival rate and median survival time after surgery, as well as to determine the association between these classifications and survival for a total of 746 CCA patients from northeast Thailand. Our results showed that most CCA patients were male (63.9%), almost twice as many as females, while the at risk population that came for CCA screening were predominately females. More than half of the 746 patients (54.6%) were elderly (aged greater than 60 years old), which is consistent with previous studies [25]. In addition, approximately two-thirds of CCA patients were found to be in late stages of the disease (65.3%) presenting with symptoms indicating CCA. This may be because the CCA screening program (CASCAP) is not comprehensive and that patients are asymptomatic, consequently they present at medical facilities when the disease has progressed and symptoms become apparent. The combination of anatomical and morphological classifications showed that the percentage of patients in the ICM group was highest (31.9%), whereas the lowest percentage was for patients in DCI group with about 2%.
The survival analyses showed that the overall incidence rate was 39.6 per 100 patients per year. The highest rate was found in the PCM group followed by the ICM and PCP groups (56.4, 49.2, and 45.6 per 100 patients per year, respectively). Likewise, compared to the  [27]. Although this was based on only 16 patients who had ICP, this discrepancy addressed issues for improving surgical outcome among this group of patients. The overall median survival times was about 18 months, the longest median survival time was 40.5 months for PCI patients, which was different when only classified anatomically when the longest median survival time was in DCCA patients (21.8 months). The shortest median survival time was found in patients with ICM (12.4 months) which was consistent with ICCA patients without morphological classification (16.2 months). The incidence rate and median survival time according to anatomical classification, and a combination of anatomical and morphological classifications separated by stage of CCA, are detailed in Additional file 1 (Table S1, Figs. S1, S2, S3, and S4). The overall survival rate was 60% at 1-year, 31% at 3-years, and 25% at 5-years. The highest survival rate was found in the patients with PCI 78.4, 52.5, and 42.6% at 1-year, 3-years, and 5-years, respectively. These rates were different when classified only anatomically, when the highest survival rate in patients with DCCA was 65% at 1 year, 37.5% at 3 years, and 34.8% at 5 years, respectively. Our finding is contrast with what was found in a study by Hang and colleagues in 2019 which showing that the highest 5-year overall survival was found in ICCA (16.7%) followed by PCCA (16.4%) and DCCA (5.7%) [16]. The large difference of the 5-year survival rate among DCCA patients between this and our study, 5.7% versus 34.8%, could caused by various factors such as cause of the disease, cancer staging at time of surgery, surgical resectability, susceptibility to lymph node dissection, etc. There is little evidences for this paper and ours. Obviously, the proportion of patient with late stage CCA in this and our study were 59.8% versus 65.3% which indicated that our study had a higher favorable surgical outcome even having a lower proportion of patients in the late. But what really plays roles here remained unclear to us. Indeed, there are limited consensus evidences regarding the factors that strongly affect surgical outcome among CCA patients. The lowest survival rate at 5-years was found in PCP patients (16%), which is lower than for PCCA patients (19%) who were classified only by anatomical characteristics. The survival rate according to the anatomical classification, and a combination of anatomical and morphological classifications separated by the stage of CCA, found that patients with early stage disease have higher survival rates than those with late stage disease (see Additional file 1 Figs. S5, S6, and S7). This is consistent with a 5-year population-based study conducted in north Thailand in 2011 which found that CCA patients with stage 0 had a 100% 3-year survival rate [8].
The association between anatomical classification and survival using cox regression, bivariate analyses found no significant associations for all groups. After controlling for the effect of other factors (stage of CCA, gender, age at enrollment, history of O. viverrini infection, education levels, occupation, cigarettes smoking history, alcohol consumption history, and praziquantel treatment) that have been previously reported as associated with CCA [25,28,29], significant associations were found in DCCA patients. According to a combination of anatomical and morphological classifications, the association of survival using simple cox regression analysis found significant associations for the patients in three groups (ICM, PCM, and PCP). Using multiple cox regression analysis by controlling for the effect of other factors, our results showed that only patients with ICM were significantly associated with overall survival compared to ICI patients. Interestingly, results from CCA patients in two groups PCM and PCP, changed from significant to non-significant from bivariate analyses compared to multivariable analyses. This may be caused by controlling for other factors in the bivariate analyses, whereas those factors cannot be ignored in multivariable analyses and models which previously found relationships with CCA [25,28,29]. Result from our study show that the strongest association was in the ICM group in which patients with a combination of ICCA and MF are most likely to die with 45% mortality (adjusted HR: 1.45; 95% CI: 1.01-2.09) compared to those who had a combination of ICCA and ID. However, when classified by only anatomical characteristics, we found that patients in the ICCA group were most likely to die 49% (HR: 1.49; 95% CI: 1.10-2.04), compared to the DCCA group. Furthermore, this effect was more than for those CCA patients with a  Limitations of the study were the demographic and some health data were self-reported leading to potential bias in the measurement of liver fluke infection, and praziquantel treatment. Self-reporting could lead to underestimates of the size of effects due to an unwillingness to disclose sensitive or personal information. Studies involving survival outcome could be affected by lead time bias. However, our study compared within the same cohort for their survival according to the anatomical and morphological classification. Mean age at diagnosis are similar across the classification group. Therefore, such bias plays no roles in our findings. We also concern about the effect of misclassification on our study due to the limitation in the diagnosis processes. However, misclassification bias may not an issue because there is no evidence of systematic misclassification, i.e., it could occurred but mainly just by chance.

Conclusions
Among CCA patients receiving surgical treatment with only an anatomical classification, the highest 5-year survival rate was found in DCCA patients, whereas the lowest was in PCCA patients. However, when classified by morphological characteristics, the survival rate was higher than when classified by anatomical features alone especially in patients with a combination of PCCA and ID. The patients in the PCI group had the longest median survival time, whereas the shortest was for patients in the ICM group. When we examined the association between a combination of anatomical and morphological classifications and survival in a high-risk population for CCA, our results revealed that patients with ICM had the strongest association compared to other groups. Based on our results, the treatment plan for CCA patients must be conducted urgently and carefully, especially in patients with PCI who are most likely to have a high survival rate. Screening for CCA is necessary and should be conducted extensively in high risk areas, including all areas throughout Thailand and mainland SE Asia in order to detect people in early stages of the disease thus assisting in prolonging their survival.
Additional file 1: Table S1. Incidence rate and median survival time of cholangiocarcinoma patients according to anatomical classification, combination of anatomical and morphological classification separated by stage of cholangiocarcinoma. Figure S1