A Bibliometric analysis of folate receptor research

Background The objective of this study was to conduct a bibliometric analysis of the entire field of folate receptor research. Folate receptor is expressed on a wide variety of cancers and certain immune cells. Methods A Web of Science search was performed on folate receptor or folate binding protein (1969-to June 28, 2019). The following information was examined: publications per year, overall citations, top 10 authors, top 10 institutions, top 10 cited articles, top 10 countries, co-author collaborations and key areas of research. Results In total, 3248 documents for folate receptor or folate binding protein were retrieved for the study years outlined in the methods section search query. The range was 1 per year in 1969 to 264 for the last full year studied (2018). A total of 123,720 citations for the 3248 documents retrieved represented a mean citation rate per article of 38.09 and range of 1667 citations (range 0 to 1667). Researchers in 71 countries authored publications analyzed in this study. The US was the leader in publications and had the highest ranking institution. The top 10 articles have been cited 7270 times during the time frame of this study. The top cited article had an average citation rate of 110 citations per year. Network maps revealed considerable co-authorship among several of the top 10 authors. Conclusion Our study presents several important insights into the features and impact of folate receptor research. To our knowledge, this is the first bibliometric analysis of folate receptor.

According to Andres [67], the term "bibliometrics" was first coined in 1969 and described as a means to apply a mathematical and statistical approach to the study of scientific literature. The term is synonymous with "scientometrics." However, for the purposes of this study we will use the term bibliometrics. As Kotepui, et al. [68], describe, bibliometric studies are used to obtain a research assessment rich with data that support a specific research interest. The data can be used to present a rich visualization about research undertakings the world round. Trends within a particular field are highlighted through descriptive analysis. Productivity can be demonstrated through the number of articles published, an author count, and by institutions or countries of origin among a myriad of other factors. Given the expansive rise in folate receptor related reports over the past several decades, we sought to analyze the entire field of FR literature. To our knowledge, this is the first bibliometric analysis of folate receptor.

Methods
For this bibliometric study the search of the available literature was conducted using the online index Web of Science by Clarivate Analytics. The Web of Science Core Collection provides regional citation indexes, patent data, specialized subject indexes, and an index of research data sets from within over 33,000 journals [69]. Using the Web of Science Core Collection, limiting for "articles," four searches were conducted as follows: "folate receptor" or "folate binding protein;" "folate receptor" or "folate binding protein" and "cancer" or "neoplasm;" "folate receptor" or "folate binding protein" and "inflammation" or "macrophage;" and "folate receptor" or "folate binding protein" and "imaging" or "diagnostics." An Excel spreadsheet was used to collect the following data for each of the four searches: total journal article search results, publication years (range), first known publication, year of publication, top ten countries/regions, top ten organizations, top ten authors, top ten citations, total citations and citations per year. Graphs for these data were performed using GraphPad Prism. VOSviewer version 1.6.11 software [70] was used to create the author co-authorship bibliometric network map (type of analysis = co-authorship, units of analysis = authors, counting method = full counting, minimum number of documents of an author = 10). Bibliometric key topic maps were constructed using VOSviewer version 1.6.11 [70] for both cancer and imaging search schemes (type of analysis = density visualization, item density, minimum number of occurrences = 50 for cancer and 25 for imaging). Based on the number of articles retrieved, we focused primarily on the first search term "folate receptor" or "folate binding protein" leaving more specific analyses for future work of the rich subfields.

Literature retrieved for Folate receptor articles
A total of 3248 documents for folate receptor or folate binding protein were retrieved for the study years outlined in the methods section search query (1969-to June 28, 2019). In this study only research articles in English were used for further analysis since English was the dominant language (99.4%) identified. Review articles, conference proceedings, book chapters, etc., were excluded from the search criteria to avoid citation bias and potential duplication of work. A summary of document types found in the search are presented in Table 1.

Publication and citation growth for Folate receptor articles
There was a dramatic increase in the number of folate receptor works during the study period (

Publications by institutions for Folate receptor articles
The total number of unique institutions represented in this study was 2351. The top 10 institutions accounted for 24.1% (754 articles) of the total number of publications (Fig. 3). Purdue University had the highest number of publications at 170 (5.2%) followed by the University of Texas System at 104 (3.2%) and the National Institutes of Health (NIH) at 75 (2.3%) to round out the top 3 counties by output. Of note, a privately held company was in 5th position at 70 research articles. The publication productivity among the top 10 institutions differed by as much as a factor of 3.5 (1st institution versus the 10th institution by rank).

Publications by authors for Folate receptor articles
The top 10 authors accounted for 18.1% (589) of the total number of research articles (Fig. 4). Low, P.S., had the highest number of publications at 139 (4.3%) followed by Holm, J. at 60 (1.8%) and Hansen, S.I., Lee, R.J., and Leamon, C.P tied at 59 (1.8%) by output. The publication productivity among the top 10 authors differed by as much as a factor of 3.6 and was consistent with institution affiliation data (1st author versus the 10th author by rank).

Top 10 citations for Folate receptor articles
The top 10 research articles by total citations are listed in Table 2 [71] (Table follows the

Folate receptor articles related to Cancer, macrophages and imaging
Since folate receptor is a well-known target for cancer therapies, modalities associated with cells of the immune system (macrophages) and imaging agents, a refined search (see methods section) was conducted. Search queries involving cancer, macrophage and imaging agents revealed 2085 articles (64.2%), 128 articles (3.9%) and 752 articles (23.2%), respectively, for each topical area. See Fig. 5. Bibliometric item intensity maps were constructed using VOSviewer version 1.6.11 [70] for both cancer and imaging (see Figs. 6 and 7).

Discussion
Folate receptor research publications increased considerably after the seminal work of Low and Leamon, which demonstrated uptake of conjugates via the folate receptor in receptor positive cancer cell lines [2].    The large co-authorship nodes in the network map mirror several of the top 10 ten authors with Low occupying the central region, which is not surprising based on the historical progression of the field. Other prominent nodes included Mueller, Lee, Baker and Leamon. Given that folate receptor expression was found to be increased on cancer versus normal tissues, this feature provided a potential pathway for production of both therapeutic and diagnostic imaging agents. In fact, imaging in this early study played a key part in elucidation of folate mediated uptake of attached cargos [2]. Clinically, populations that will benefit from such targeted therapies need to be identified for treatment. This has been underscored by FDA guidance on the use of companion diagnostic for targeted therapies [73]. In addition to folate based MRI, CT, SPECT, PET and NIR imaging modalities [74], folate targeted agents are currently being explored for image-guided surgery for dubulkment of ovarian cancer tissue [75]. In our analysis, a folate guided surgery publication was the 5th most cited.
Moreover, our study detected an appreciable number of review articles (426 total) in addition to primary research articles that could be analyzed in future studies. A recent report by Blumel and Shniederman, based on inputs from the Conference of the International Society of Informetrics [76], proposes a broad agenda for the study of review articles. However, including such sizable numbers review articles within the framework of our current analyses would have been problematic. For instance, Ho [77] illustrates that review papers introduce bias in citation based analysis and that scholars must consider the purpose of the study and treat review papers distinctly to avoid this bias. Similar concerns have been earlier noted by Knottnerus [78]. There are also divergent definitions of what constitutes a review article including issues pointed out with WoS versus other databases noted by Ketcham [79].
The United States was the top article producing country followed by China and India. This is consistent with the output of Low (Purdue), Leamon (Endocyte), Lee (The Ohio State University), and the company Endoycte based in Purdue Research Park. There was a wide variation of publication productivity among the top 10 countries (differing by as much as a factor of 14.9 from the 1st country versus the 10th country by rank). Large state and federal (universities and institutes) and systems made up a large share of the top 10 institutions (e.g., Purdue, University of Texas, Chinese Academy of Sciences and NIH) with the notable exception of the private company Endocyte. The top 10 cited articles revealed a high proportion of therapeutic and imaging related studies. Specifically, several works outline the use of folate-guided nanomaterials agents for detection and treatment of folate receptor positive cancers. Folate is easily conjugated to various nanomaterials and several high receptor expressing cancer cell lines exist for testing these nanoconjugates [72]. The field of nanomedicine, in general, also experienced rapid citation growth during this time frame [80]. An analysis of citation rates per time,  [81]. Hutchins et al. take it a step further and utilize a relative citation ratio whereby citation rates are divided by an expected citation rate that is a derivation from other articles in the same field within a peer comparison group [82]. This concept while not employed in this study, can be explored for further applications within the rich subfields of folate research.
Cancer was a key word associated with the majority of papers, followed by imaging and macrophages. Item density analyses of folate receptor subset areas yielded key topics including: nanoparticle, cytotoxicity, delivery, efficiency, expression, ovarian cancer, and fluorescence imaging, These areas were heavily represented in the top cited articles, especially articles associated with nanotechnology as previously outlined.
In fact, the top two cited articles in folate receptor research were in nanotechnology. This information could be used to help guide further analyses in this area of research.
This study has limitations that are related to the exclusive use of Web of Science. As Zyoud et al., cites English is the indisputable language of science, but this in itself is a limitation for bibliometric studies as databases omit publications written in other languages [83]. Web of Science was chosen for this study because, as Chen states, its records are standardized and more consistent than competitors [84]. The authors acknowledge that different databases will return different items. However, as Mansoori noted, Web of Science offered better tools to refine and analyze searches than Scopus [85].

Conclusions
Folate receptor research has led to the development of promising drug, imaging and other diagnostic schemes as well has had a profound impact on our understanding of receptor mediated cellular pathways. In this study, Web of Science was used to assess the global scientific production ranging from 1969-to June 28, 2019. Results illustrated a substantial increase in the cumulative volume of papers (264 per year for the last year studied). The US held the top metrics in publications, institutions and author output. The top 10 cited articles had an appreciable number of imaging and therapeutic applications, including nanotechnology. Given the different subareas of this dataset (e.g. imaging), there exists a rich source of data for further studies. Through bibliometric analysis, it should be possible to elucidate further interesting trends in these areas.