Skip to main content

Promoting breast health among female adolescents: a comparative analysis of the effects of two didactic tools on knowledge and practice regarding breast self-examination in Southwest Nigeria

Abstract

Background

Teaching effective methods for breast self-examination (BSE) to adolescent females is essential for promoting early detection and improving outcomes in breast cancer management. This study therefore aimed to compare two pedagogical tools for teaching BSE among adolescent females.

Methods

A quasi-experimental design with a group for pre- and post-intervention tests was adopted. The sample included 970 female senior secondary school class I-III students. The Yamane formula was used to determine a sample size of 276. Pre- and post-intervention data were collected using an observation checklist for practice and a validated questionnaire with a Cronbach’s alpha coefficient of 0.76 for knowledge of BSE. A proportionate stratified random sampling technique was used to determine the number of participants for each group. Among the 276 participants, 161 were taught the traditional method (TM), i.e., a lecture, and 115 were taught using the modern method (MM) by watching a podcast that contained BSE lessons. Post-intervention data were collected after six weeks. The data were analysed using descriptive and inferential statistics at a 5% level of significance to compare the effectiveness of the methods.

Results

The findings of this study showed that the participants’ mean ages across the two methods were 15.49 ± 1.65 and 15.43 ± 1.40 years for the traditional method (TM) and modern method (MM), respectively. Pre-intervention mean BSE knowledge scores in both the TM and MM groups were 8.19 ± 3.17 and 8.31 ± 2.39, respectively, and BSE practice scores were 7.17 ± 2.48 and 6.44 ± 2.75, respectively. Post-intervention knowledge mean scores in both the TM and MM groups increased to 13.75 ± 4.09 and 16.92 ± 2.91, respectively, and post-intervention practice scores increased to 13.06 ± 2.74 and 15.68 ± 3.12, respectively.

Conclusion

This study revealed that both teaching methods were effective at teaching breast self-examination among female adolescents; nevertheless, modern methods are more effective at teaching breast self-examination among female adolescents.

Peer Review reports

Introduction

Breast cancer (BC) remains a leading cause of cancer-related deaths among women globally, with a rising incidence among younger populations [1, 2]. It is the most frequent cause of death among women and estimated that 70% of all breast cancer cases worldwide were reported in low and middle-resource countries [3, 4]. In addition, many Sub-Saharan African countries including Nigeria are among the countries with the highest breast cancer mortality worldwide, reflecting weak health infrastructure and subsequently poor survival outcomes because of late presentation [5].

In Nigeria, breast cancer is the most common cancer among women, accounting for 25% of all cancer cases [6, 7]. Nigeria has also been reported to have the highest breast cancer mortality rate in Sub-Sahara Africa [6, 8].

Breast self-examination (BSE) is a basic, most significant, highly endorsed, crucial skill for the early discovery of breast cancer [8], particularly among young females who may not undergo or afford other regular clinical screenings, especially in developing countries. According to the WHO, the teaching of young girls [9] has been viewed as a modality that can promote health and prevent disease among women, and any foundation of good health laid at this stage of life can last longer. In addition, the study of Udeze et al. [10], Asuquo & Olajide [11] and Pangestuti et al. [12] averred that adolescence is seen as a crucial time for the establishment of lifetime habits. Healthy habits developed in adolescence are carried throughout adulthood. Consequently, adolescent girls are therefore a crucial target audience for breast cancer education and awareness-raising. Hence, teaching young women how to perform breast self-examination (BSE) is an optimistic approach for reducing breast cancer morbidity and mortality in societies [13, 14].

However, despite the established importance of breast self-examination (BSE) in early breast cancer detection, recent incidence rates indicate a persistent gap in knowledge and practice among young females. Existing studies [15,16,17] have emphasized the significance of teaching BSE to adolescent females, yet many still lack the necessary skills and knowledge.

Conversely, the effectiveness of various pedagogical tools for teaching BSE, such as video teaching, lectures, peer group discussions, and pamphlets, in enhancing BSE knowledge and practice remains unclear. This study aims to address this knowledge gap by comparing the effectiveness of traditional (lecture) and modern (podcast) methods in teaching BSE to adolescent females. By assessing the impact of these methods on BSE knowledge and practices, this research seeks to identify the most efficient approach for educating adolescents on breast self-examination, ultimately contributing to the reduction of breast cancer morbidity and mortality in this vulnerable population.

Hypothesis

H0: There is no significant difference between pre-and post-intervention knowledge of breast self-examination using traditional and modern methods.

H0: There is no significant difference between the pre-and post-intervention practice of breast self-examination using traditional and modern methods.

Materials and methods

Study design and settings

This was a quasi-experimental design with pre- and post-intervention tests without a control group conducted among female secondary school (SS) students from December 2022 to April 2023. The study settings were government-owned secondary schools in two separate zones (Ogbomoso and Oyo towns) in Oyo state, South-Western Nigeria. The secondary schools selected in the Ogbomoso zone were Ogbomoso High School, Ogbomoso, and the Anglican Grammar School, Ogbomoso. The Oyo zone included the Ladigbolu Grammar School, Oyo, and the Durbar Grammar School, Oyo. All of the schools are mixed and day school.

The interventions involved teaching female secondary school students about the knowledge and practice of breast self-examination using traditional methods and modern methods. Participants in Ogbomoso zone were taught breast self-examination using traditional methods, while those in Oyo zone were taught using modern methods.

Participants and procedures

The study was conducted among 276 female participants from a population of participants that included all females in senior secondary (SS) classes 1–3 of the four schools (N = 970). The sample size was calculated using Yamane’s formula (n = N/(1 + N(e)2). The study sample from each school was determined using the proportional stratified random sampling procedure. Each stratum sample size in this method was exactly proportionate to the size of the strata’s total population. A total of 276 participants participated in both the pre- and post-tests. A total of 161 participants were in the traditional group, while 115 participants were in the modern group. The inclusion criteria included: being a female in SS class I, II or III and being aged 13-19years old. The exclusion criteria included: being a female in junior secondary classes I, II or III and male students were excluded.

Pre-visiting to the schools was performed to familiarize the participants with the purpose and benefit of the study. Confidentiality was assured. Permission was sought from the school head as an agreed-upon convenient time for readiness of the participants. Those younger than 18 years were given a parental consent form.

Three phases were then used to conduct the study: the pre-intervention phase, the intervention phase, and the post-intervention phase.

Pre-intervention phase

Pre-intervention tests were performed using both instruments (questionnaire and observational checklist) for the two groups.

Intervention phase

Teaching tools such as leaflets/pamphlets showing images of the steps of conducting BSE and audio-visual aids were used during this phase. However, the traditional group was taught using the lecture method, while the modern group was taught with audio-visual information (watching a podcast) based on the content of the questionnaire and checklist. The teaching was prepared and delivered in English, which is the general language. Training for each group took one and a half hours (90 min). Each participant was given a unique identification tag that could be traced back during the post-test. Both the pre-test and the intervention were conducted on the same day.

Post-intervention phase

After six weeks of intervention, the participants were re-contacted for the post-test using the same questions from the pre-test questionnaire. The effectiveness of the two methods of teaching was subsequently compared.

Study instrument

Two instruments used to collect data in this study were self-developed validated questionnaire and observation checklists. The questionnaire included information on participants’ demographic variables and questions on their knowledge of and practices related to breast self-examination, while an observational checklist was used to test participants’ knowledge of and practices related to BSE (See Appendix 1).

The contents of the observational checklist comprised the processes of carrying out BSE, which included physical assessment, palpation, and five steps. Each of the items was graded to a total of 20 points (See Appendix 1).

These instruments were subjected for correction, appropriate opinion, clarity and all-inclusiveness of the constructs by external reviewer and other experts in the field. The instruments were made to pass through the face and content validity. All the corrections made were implemented before the administration of the instrument.

A pilot study was conducted to test the reliability of the instrument among participants who were not included in the study. The reliability coefficient was 0.76.

Statistical analysis

Descriptive (frequency, percentage, mean and standard deviation) and inferential (independent t-test) statistics were used to analyse the data using SPSS version 23 to examine the differences in the mean scores of the two groups before and after the intervention.

Ethical considerations

The Institutional Research Ethics guidelines and the ethical principle pertaining to human participation were followed in the conduct of the study. (i.e., Helsinki Declaration). The researcher obtained formal ethical approval from the Oyo State Ministry of Education with reference number EDU215/T8VOL1/90. Permission to carry out the study was also obtained from the principal of each school. Students were gathered together during break time, and the purpose of the study was explained to them. Participants were informed that this was a three-phase study and about the duration of the study and the approximate time that would be taken from them. The students who were ready for education completed the informed consent form. Parental consent was obtained from those younger than 18 years via administration of parental informed consent form.

Results

General characteristics of the participants

Table 1 shows the demographic characteristics of the female adolescents in the traditional and modern secondary school groups in the study, with mean ages of 15.49 ± 1.65 and 15.43 ± 1.40 years, respectively. Additionally, the results revealed that 141 (87.6%) and 103 (89.6%) of the participants were aged 14–17 years, respectively. The majority of the participants—87 (54%) and 56 (54%)—were in SS I, and the others were in SS II and III, respectively. Above average (70.2%) and 59 (51.3%) of the students reached menarche between the ages of 10–13 years; 47 (29.2%) and 56 (48.7%) started between 14 and 17 years of age, while only 1 (0.6%) reached menarche at 18 years. The majority (133; 82.6%) and (96; 83.5%) of the participants’ fathers had education up to the secondary level, while 130 (80.7%) and 90 (78.2%) mothers had education up to the secondary level, respectively. Almost all the participants were of the Yoruba ethnic group.

Table 1 Demographic characteristics of participants under traditional and modern methods of teaching (N = 276)

Comparative analysis of the effects of two didactic tools on knowledge and practices related to breast self-examination among female adolescents

Table 2 shows the results of knowledge of breast self-examination among female adolescents showed that the modern approach was more effective than the traditional method. The mean gain of the modern method is 8.6087, while that of the traditional method is 5.5528.

Table 2 Mean score differences in BSE knowledge pre- and post-intervention

Table 3 shows the difference in the mean score between modern and traditional methods with regard to the practice of breast self-examination. The mean gain in the traditional era was 5.8981, and that in the modern era was 9.2348.

Table 3 Presents the pre- and post-intervention mean score of practice of breast self-examination

Table 4 shows that among the participants, there was no significant difference between the mean score of pre-intervention knowledge of breast self-examination using traditional and modern methods (Crit-t = 1.96, Cal.t = -0.343, DF = 274, p(0.732) > 0.05 level of significance).

Table 4 Showing the difference in the mean scores of pre- and post-intervention knowledge of breast self-examination using traditional and modern methods among female adolescents

Nonetheless, there was a statistically significant difference in postintervention knowledge of breast self-examination among female adolescents (Cal.t = -2.643, DF = 274, p(0.009) < 0.05 level of significance). Hence, knowledge of breast self-examination among female adolescents using modern methods was more effective than traditional methods.

In terms of the practice of breast self-examination, there was a statistically significant difference among the participants who used both educational tools (Cal.t = 2.225, DF = 274, p(0.027) < 0.05 level of significance). However, the use of modern methods was more effective than the use of traditional methods in the post-test (Table 5).

Table 5 Showing the difference in the mean scores of pre- and post-intervention BSE practices using traditional and modern methods

Discussion

The study revealed that education using both traditional and modern techniques had a positive impact on participants’ knowledge and practical abilities related to breast self-examination. The findings of this study revealed that teaching using both traditional and modern approaches improves BSE, and this finding is corroborated by research conducted by Tewelde et al. [18], Juanita et al. [19] and Ahmed et al. [20] on educational programmes on BSE knowledge and practice.

In this study, the pre- and post-intervention mean gains of knowledge and practice of BSE using traditional methods increased from 8.1925 to 13.7453 and from 7.1671 to 13.0652, respectively. This revealed an improvement in their knowledge and practice of BSE after using an interventional tool. In agreement with this, Ayran et al. [21] reported that although participants’ BSE knowledge and practices were lacking before BSE peer education, BSE knowledge and practices significantly improved following BSE peer education. This finding is similar to the findings of the present study. Furthermore, Ozturk et al. [22] showed notable variations between BSE practices and knowledge before and after an educational intervention. Additionally, a study by Seif & Aziz [23] revealed that following education, participants’ knowledge and BSE behaviours increased to 95.1% and 86%, respectively, from 15% to 5.2%, respectively, before education.

This study also revealed that the pre- and post-intervention mean gains of knowledge and practice of BSE using the modern (podcast) method improved from 8.3130 to 16.9217 and from 6.4409 to 15.6757, respectively. This finding is in agreement with a study conducted in Ethiopia where the level of knowledge of the participants increased from 37.7 to 57.4%, and the level of practice also increased from 16.4 to 70.3% following a planned teaching intervention.

However, a notable finding in this study is the superior effectiveness of the modern method (podcast) in teaching breast self-examination (BSE) knowledge and practice among adolescents compared to the traditional method. The mean differences in the pre-post intervention knowledge of BSE using traditional and modern methods were 5.5528 and 8.6087, respectively, while the pre-post-intervention knowledge of BSE using traditional methods was 5.8981 and 9.2348, respectively. This suggests that the modern method was significantly more effective than the traditional method. This outcome may be attributed to today’s adolescents being more visual and inclined towards interactive learning, as opposed to traditional auditory learning. Furthermore, technological advancements have enabled the use of modern tools such as podcasts and the internet to reach a wider audience, making health education more accessible and engaging. Consistent with this finding, a study by Tuna [24] revealed that internet education significantly improved the knowledge and practices of BSE among participants. Other studies [25, 26] have also highlighted the effectiveness of modern educational methods in promoting a positive mind set towards breast cancer prevention.

Limitations

Due to time constraint, follow up session of educational intervention on knowledge and practice of BSE could not be done. Participants were not given remind to practice BSE during the interval period. School holiday period brought about the longer interval time resulting in forgetfulness of the process by the participants.

Conclusion

It is concluded in this study that both traditional (lecture) and modern (podcast) methods are useful tools for effectively teaching breast self-examination, but modern methods are more significantly effective at teaching BSE among female adolescents who are inclined with technology. A future study among other categories of women is recommended to assess the effectiveness of these educational tools.

Data availability

The datasets used and analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Abbreviations

BSE:

Breast Self-Examination

SS:

Senior Secondary

References

  1. Bray F, Laversanne M, Sung H, Ferlay J, Siegel RL, Soerjomataram I, Jemal A. Global Cancer statistics 2022: GLOBOCAN estimates of incidence and Mortality Worldwide for 36 cancers in 185 countries. Cancer J Clin. 2024;74(3):229–63.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  2. Xu S, Murtagh S, Han Y, Wan F, Toriola AT. Breast Cancer incidence among US women aged 20 to 49 years by race, stage, and hormone receptor status. JAMA Netw Open. 2024;7(1):e2353331.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  3. Lera T, Beyene A, Bekele B, Abreha S. Breast self-examination and Associated Factors among women in Wolaita Sodo, Ethiopia: A Community-based cross-sectional study. BMC Womens Health. 2020;20:1–0.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  4. Asmare K, Birhanu Y, Wako Z, Knowledge. Attitude, practice towards breast self-examination and Associated Factors among women in Gondar Town, Northwest Ethiopia, 2021: a community-based study. BMC Womens Health. 2022;22(1):174.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  5. Soerjomataram I, Cabasag C, Bardot A, Fidler-Benaoudia MM, Miranda-Filho A, Ferlay J, Parkin DM, Ranganathan R, Piñeros M, Znaor A, Mery L. Cancer survival in Africa, central and south America, and Asia (SURVCAN-3): a Population-based Benchmarking study in 32 countries. Lancet Oncol. 2023;24(1):22–32.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  6. Ntekim A, Oluwasanu M, Odukoya O. Breast Cancer in adolescents and young adults less than 40 years of age in Nigeria: a retrospective analysis. Int J Breast cancer. 2022;2022(1):9943247.

    PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  7. Fatiregun OA, Oluokun T, Lasebikan NN, Nwachukwu E, Ibraheem AA, Olopade O. Breast Cancer Research to support evidence-based medicine in Nigeria: a review of the literature. JCO Global Oncol. 2021;7:384–90.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  8. Azubuike SO, Muirhead C, Hayes L, McNally R. Rising global burden of breast Cancer: the case of Sub-saharan Africa (with emphasis on Nigeria) and implications for Regional Development: a review. World J Surg Oncol. 2018;16:1–3.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  9. Ekim A, Subaşı DÖ, Ocakçı AF. Effect of breast Cancer awareness education in adolescent girls: a quasi-experimental study. J Educ Res Nursing/Hemşirelikte Eğitim ve Araştırma Dergisi. 2024;21(2).

  10. Udeze CN, Ezenwa MO, Abamara NC. Effect of Cancer Education on the practice of breast self-examination among adult women in Nigeria. Cogent Psychol. 2020;7(1):1823616.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  11. Asuquo IM, Olajide TE. The role of Health education on breast Cancer awareness among University of Calabar Female Undergraduates. J Educ Pract. 2015;6(24):151–61.

    Google Scholar 

  12. Pangestuti RD, Armini NKA, Dewi LC. Self-structured breast Cancer awareness among female adolescent. Pediomaternal Nurs J. 2021;7(1):1–7.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  13. Ibitoye OF, Thupayegale-Tshwenegae G. The impact of education on knowledge, attitude and practice of breast self-examination among adolescents girls at the Fiwasaye Girls Grammar School Akure, Nigeria. J Cancer Educ. 2021;36(1):39–46.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  14. Abaribe CE, Okafor N, Olu-Abiodun O, Joshua O, Dike C. Breast self-examination among female adolescents in Nigeria: an integrative review. Midwifery. 2023;6(2):87–98.

    Google Scholar 

  15. Tewelde B, Tamire M, Kaba M. Breast Self–Examination Practice and Predictors among Female Secondary School Teachers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: using the Health Belief Model. BMC Womens Health [Internet]. 2022;22(317):1–8. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-022-01904-w

  16. Juanita PJ, Umaporn B. Effect of Cultural-based breast self-examination Educational Program on BSE Self-Efficacy among nursing student, Indonesia. Advancing knowledge, Research and Technology for Humanity. Banda Aceh; 2017. pp. 89–98.

  17. Ahmed HAM, Ahmed EAA, Aljaber NY. The effect of breast self-examination Training Program on the knowledge, attitude and practice among female nursing students at Faculty of Nursing, Alexandria University, Egypt. IOSR J Nurs Heal Sci. 2018;7(1):42–9.

    Google Scholar 

  18. Ayran G, Firat M, Kucukakca G, Cuneydioglu B, Tahta K, Avci E. The effect of peer education upon breast self- examination behaviors and self-esteem among University students. Eur J Breast Heal. 2017;13(3):138–44.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  19. Öztürk M, Engin V, Kişioğlu A, Yılmazer G. Effects of Education on Knowledge and attitude of breast self examination among 25 + Years Old women. East J Med. 2000;5(1):13–7.

    Google Scholar 

  20. Seif N, Aziz M. Effect of breast self examination training program on knowledge, attitude and practice of a Group of Working Women. J Egypt Nat Cancer Inst. 2000;12:105–15.

    Google Scholar 

  21. Tuna A, Avdal EU, Yucel SC, Dal NA, Dicle A, Ozkan A, et al. Effectiveness of online education in teaching breast self-examination. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev. 2014;15(7):3227–31.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  22. Shaffer V, Owens J, Zikmund-Fisher B. The effect of patient narratives on information search in a web-based breast Cancer decision aid: an Eye-Tracking Study. J Med Internet Res. 2013;15(273).

  23. Valero-Aguilera B, Bermúdez-Tamayo C, García-Gutiérrez JF, Jiménez-Pernett J, Cózar-Olmo JM, Guerrero-Tejada R, et al. Information needs and internet use in urological and breast Cancer patients. Support Cancer Care. 2014;22:545–52.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  24. Tuna A, Avdal EU, Yucel SC, Dal NA, Dicle A, Ozkan A, et al. Effectiveness of online education in teaching breast self-examination. Asian Pacific J Cancer Prev. 2014;15(7):3227–31.

  25. Shaffer V, Owens J, Zikmund-Fisher B. The effect of patient narratives on information search in a web-based breast cancer decision aid: an eye-tracking study. J Med internet Res. 2013;15(273).

  26. Valero-Aguilera B, Bermúdez-Tamayo C, García-Gutiérrez JF, Jiménez-Pernett J, Cózar-Olmo JM, Guerrero-Tejada R, et al. Information needs and internet use in urological and breast cancer patients. Support Cancer Care. 2014;22:545–52.

Download references

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to express gratitude to all the respondents who participated in this study.

Funding

The authors did not receive support from any organization.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Contributions

Conceptualization: E.O., J.O. and R.A.Initial manuscript: E.O. and D.E.Data curation: E.O., D.E., T.A., A.O., T.O. and R.G.Methodology: E.O. and O.I.Statistical analysis: D.E. and O.I.All authors reviewed the manuscript.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Eunice Oluwakemi Ogunmodede.

Ethics declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Approval was obtained from the ethics committee of Oyo State Ministry of Education. The procedures used in this study adhere to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki. Informed consent was obtained from all participants aged ≥ 18 years and the parents of those < 18 years included in the study. Parents of those < 18 years old signed informed consent.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

Additional information

Publisher’s note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Electronic supplementary material

Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.

Supplementary Material 1

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License, which permits any non-commercial use, sharing, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if you modified the licensed material. You do not have permission under this licence to share adapted material derived from this article or parts of it. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/.

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Ogunmodede, E.O., Ajala, D.E., Aluko, J.O. et al. Promoting breast health among female adolescents: a comparative analysis of the effects of two didactic tools on knowledge and practice regarding breast self-examination in Southwest Nigeria. BMC Cancer 24, 1183 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12885-024-12949-5

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12885-024-12949-5

Keywords