Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparison of predictive performance of models for prognosis in TCGA patients with RT

From: Prediction of radiosensitivity and radiocurability using a novel supervised artificial neural network

Cohorts

ANN-SCGP

LASSO CPH

ANN

CPH

RSF

RSI

C-index (CV1)

C-index (CV2)

C-index (CV1)

C-index (CV2)

C-index (CV1)

C-index (CV2)

C-index (CV1)

C-index (CV2)

C-index (CV1)

C-index (CV2)

C-index (CV1)

C-index (CV2)

LGG

Training

0.958

0.964

0.869

0.840

0.870

0.903

1.000

1.000

0.930

0.944

0.675

0.658

Testing

0.787

0.815

0.825

0.794

0.753

0.716

OP

OP

0.839

0.798

0.658

0.675

HNSC

Training

0.928

0.937

0.790

0.820

0.770

0.784

1.000

1.000

0.916

0.934

0.524

0.522

Testing

0.609

0.576

0.629

0.582

0.570

0.558

0.571

OP

0.608

0.568

0.522

0.524

CESC

Training

0.976

0.972

NA

0.891

0.920

0.881

1.000

1.000

0.927

0.961

0.539

0.548

Testing

0.698

0.623

NA

0.646

0.802

0.658

OP

OP

0.618

0.626

0.548

0.539

SARC

Training

0.948

0.983

0.919

0.732

0.953

0.905

1.000

1.000

0.934

0.955

0.711

0.559

Testing

0.715

0.621

OP

0.597

0.651

0.592

OP

0.692

0.682

0.720

OP

OP

STAD

Training

0.890

0.981

0.877

0.913

0.881

0.919

1.000

1.000

0.877

0.944

0.699

0.631

Testing

0.906

0.730

0.538

0.558

0.761

0.727

0.631

0.521

0.756

0.656

0.631

0.699

UCEC

Training

1.000

0.957

1.000

0.936

1.000

0.936

1.000

1.000

NA

NA

0.783

0.532

Testing

0.702

0.826

0.638

0.783

0.702

0.957

OP

OP

NA

NA

0.532

0.783

ESCA

Training

1.000

1.000

0.895

0.971

0.947

0.882

1.000

1.000

0.885

NA

0.842

0.794

Testing

0.613

OP

OP

0.868

OP

OP

0.516

0.581

0.516

NA

OP

OP

LUAD

Training

0.990

0.817

0.620

0.875

0.750

0.663

1.000

1.000

0.923

0.942

0.644

0.548

Testing

0.692

0.683

0.577

0.481

0.567

0.548

OP

OP

0.567

OP

0.548

0.644

PAAD

Training

0.964

0.888

0.813

NA

0.855

0.838

1.000

1.000

0.928

0.900

0.554

0.600

Testing

0.663

0.639

OP

NA

0.625

0.596

OP

OP

0.550

OP

0.600

0.554

LUSC

Training

0.982

0.938

0.754

0.979

0.754

0.729

1.000

1.000

0.930

0.917

0.588

0.563

Testing

0.563

0.772

OP

OP

OP

0.667

OP

0.614

0.542

0.526

OP

OP

  1. ANN Artificial neural networks, CPH Cox proportional hazard model, RSF Random survival forest, RSI Radiosensitivity index in Torres-Roca's study, OP the prediction directions of training and testing values were opposite, CV Cross validation, NA Not available