Skip to main content

Table 2 Results of meta-analyses of toxicities reported in randomized controlled trials with weekly versus three-weekly docetaxel

From: The influence of docetaxel schedule on treatment tolerability and efficacy in patients with metastatic breast cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Toxicity

No. studies

Ref

Weekly

Totals

n/N

Three-weekly

Totals

n/N

Pooled RR

95% CI

p

I2 (%)

Pq

Ï„2

Grade 3/4

 Neutropenia

3

[22, 23, 25]

14/179

87/177

0.16

0.10 – 0.27

 < 0.001

0

0.67

0

 Febrile Neutropenia

3

[22, 23, 25]

5/179

27/177

0.21

0.08 – 0.55

 < 0.01

0

0.48

0

 Neuropathy

4

[22,23,24,25]

5/227

20/231

0.29

0.11 – 0.78

0.01

0

0.66

0

 Infections

3

[22, 24, 25]

10/168

9/172

1.11

0.45 – 2.73

0.82

0

0.62

0

 Fatigue/Asthenia

3

[22, 23, 25]

23/179

28/177

0.81

0.48–1.37

0.44

1

0.36

0.003

 Fluid retention/edema/effusions

4

[22,23,24,25]

13/227

8/231

1.49

0.44 – 5.02

0.52

31

0.23

0.472

 Skin toxicity

3

[22, 24, 25]

19/168

9/172

2.04

0.75 – 5.56

0.16

34

0.22

0.269

 Nausea a

4

[22,23,24,25]

11/227

15/231

0.74

0.31–1.78

0.50

12

0.33

0.094

 Vomiting a

4

[22,23,24,25]

12/227

14/231

0.85

0.30–2.37

0.75

32

0.22

0.358

 Diarrhea

3

[22, 24, 25]

8/168

17/172

0.50

0.22–1.14

0.10

0

0.67

0

 ≥ Grade 3 or leading to treatment withdrawal

 Epiphora/lacrimation

2

[22, 23]

13/100

3/100

3.62

1.07–12.22

0.04

0

0.47

0

 ≥ Grade 2 or leading to treatment withdrawal

 Onycholysis b,c

2

[22, 25]

16/120

4/118

3.90

1.34 – 11.32

0.01

0

0.79

0

Other

 Patient withdrawals due to toxicity

2

[22, 25]

43/120

27/118

1.52

1.00 – 2.32

0.05

11

0.29

0.011

  1. n number of patients with an event in the treatment arm, N Total number of patients in the treatment arm, RR risk ratio, CI confidence interval, Pq p-value for heterogeneity, I2 measure of statistical heterogeneity, Ï„2 between-study variance
  2. aEvents from studies where combined outcome was reported cases were counted in both separate analyzed toxicities
  3. bGrade cut off based on largest group available for analysis
  4. cRef. [23] not included in analysis since no grade 2 onycholysis reported