Skip to main content

Table 1 Clinical descriptors of the derivation and validation cohorts at the baseline

From: Artificial neural networks improve LDCT lung cancer screening: a comparative validation study

 

Derivation cohort (N = 602)

Validation cohort (N = 234)

P b

Cancer (N = 19)

Control c (N = 583)

Cancer (N = 8)

Control c (N = 226)

 

Sex a

 Male

7 (36.84%)

236 (40.48%)

2 (25.00%)

111 (49.12%)

0.038

 Female

12 (63.16%)

347 (59.52%)

6 (75.00%)

115 (50.88%)

 

Age (y) a

64.89 ± 7.53

61.87 ± 6.42

57.63 ± 8.73

61.05 ± 7.88

0.053

LDCT parameters

 Dose (mSv) a

1.95 ± 0.64

1.46 ± 0.24

1.78 ± 0.45

1.49 ± 0.26

0.161

 DLP (mGy.cm) a

75.53 ± 32.54

49.17 ± 11.08

64.50 ± 24.43

50.77 ± 10.72

0.206

Pattern of nodules

 Nodules of interest a

2.42 (1–7)

1.11 (0–32)

1.88 (1–7)

1.29 (0–8)

0.330

 Number of involved lobes a

1.68 (1–3)

0.75 (0–5)

1.38 (1–4)

0.99 (0–5)

0.007

Size of nodules (mm)

 Solid nodule a

10.01 (0–136.00)

1.49 (0–19.80)

0.63 (0–5.00)

1.80 (0–36.75)

1.000

 PS nodule a

3.89 (0–20.40)

0.38 (0–11.95)

1.77 (0–4.90)

0.54 (0–7.30)

0.498

 GGN a

8.87 (0–31.00)

0.58 (0–23.30)

4.56 (0–10.30)

0.24 (0–9.05)

0.038

 Calcified nodule a

0.00 (0)

0.39 (0–19.25)

0.86 (0–6.90)

0.55 (0–7.05)

0.100

 Fat-containing nodule a

0.00 (0)

0.05 (0–28.15)

0.00 (0)

0.00 (0)

0.506

Intra-pulmonary findings

 Linear atelectasis a

10 (52.63%)

431 (73.93%)

2 (25.00%)

108 (47.79%)

< 0.001

 Plate-like atelectasis a

5 (26.32%)

73 (12.52%)

0 (0.00%)

19 (8.41%)

0.050

 Plate-like GGN a

2 (10.53%)

143 (24.53%)

1 (12.50%)

39 (17.26%)

0.029

 Bronchiectasis a

0 (0.00%)

39 (6.69%)

1 (12.50%)

8 (3.54%)

0.143

 Emphysema a

1 (5.26%)

51 (8.75%)

2 (25.00%)

28 (12.39%)

0.068

 Fibrotic change a

2 (10.53%)

154 (26.42%)

0 (0.00%)

42 (18.58%)

0.015

Extra-pulmonary findings

 Mediastinal tumour a

4 (21.05%)

30 (5.15%)

1 (12.50%)

8 (3.54%)

0.290

 Thyroid nodule a

1 (5.26%)

19 (3.26%)

0 (0.00%)

2 (0.88%)

0.045

 Adrenal nodule a

1 (5.26%)

5 (0.86%)

0 (0.00%)

0 (0.00%)

0.125

 Hepatic nodule a

1 (5.26%)

67 (11.49%)

0 (0.00%)

20 (8.85%)

0.245

 Renal nodule a

0 (0.00%)

16 (2.74%)

0 (0.00%)

10 (4.42%)

0.229

Lung-RADS

 Category 1

0 (0.00%)

323 (55.40%)

0 (0.00%)

115 (50.89%)

0.240

 Category 2

6 (31.58%)

222 (38.08%)

7 (87.50%)

102 (45.13%)

0.021

 Category 3

5 (26.32%)

31 (5.32%)

1 (12.50%)

6 (2.65%)

0.080

 Category 4

8 (42.10%)

7 (1.20%)

0 (0.00%)

3 (1.33%)

0.279

  1. a The 22 input features for developing the ANN
  2. b Comparison of the derivation cohort and validation cohort, P-values less than 0.05 indicated statistical significance
  3. c Participant who did not have confirmed lung cancer prior to the index date were labelled as control
  4. BMI body mass index; DLP dose length product; GGN ground-glass nodule; PS nodule, part-solid nodule
  5. The values are given as the mean ± SD, range or n (%)