Skip to main content

Table 2 Perioperative outcomes and recurrence pattern

From: RETRACTED ARTICLE: Comparison of minimally invasive Ivor Lewis esophagectomy and left transthoracic esophagectomy in esophageal squamous cell carcinoma patients: a propensity score-matched analysis

Characteristica

MIILE (n = 216)

Sweet (n = 216)

p value

Total surgical time(min)

265.5(214~330)

201.0(180~236)

< 0.001

Blood loss(ml)

200(150~300)

300(250~400)

< 0.001

Blood transfusion, n(%)

14(6.5)

18(8.3)

0.462

Lymphadenectomy, n

 RLN

7(3~10)

3(2~4)

< 0.001

 Thoracic

14(9~19)

10(6~14)

< 0.001

 Abdominal

10(6~15)

9(5~14)

0.034

Total

31(22~40)

18(12~28)

< 0.001

 Initiation of oral intake, d

6(5~7)

9(7~11)

< 0.001

Length of stay, d

 Intensive care unit

4(2~6)

3(2~6)

0.629

 Postoperative hospital

13(11~16)

18(16~25)

< 0.001

Complications, n(%)

 Anastomotic leak

15/216 (6.9)

16/216(7.4)

0.852

 Esophagotracheal fistula

3/216(1.4)

2/216(0.9)

0.653

 Atrial fibrillation

56/216(25.9)

67/216 (31.0)

0.241

 Pneumonia

80/216(37.0)

104/216(48.1)

0.020

 ARDS

8/216(3.7)

11/216(5.1)

0.481

 Recurrent laryngeal nerve injury

6/216(2.8)

1/216(0.5)

0.057

 Chylothorax

8/216(3.7)

7/216(3.2)

0.793

 Wound infection

11/216(5.1)

13/216(6.0)

0.674

 Ileus

3/216(1.4)

0/216(0.0)

0.248

 Volvulus

1/216(0.5)

0/216(0.0)

1.000

Totalb

110/216(50.9)

148/216(68.5)

< 0.001

 Reoperation, n(%)

19(8.8)

17(7.9)

0.728

 Mortality within postoperative-30-day,n

5

6

0.760

Recurrence, n(%)

 Locoregional recurrence

42/89(47.2)

56/95(58.9)

0.108

 Anastomosis site

4/42(9.5)

3/56(5.3)

0.703

 Cervical/supraclavicular- lymph node

4/42(9.5)

9/56(16.1)

0.159

 Mediastinal lymph node

18/42(42.9)

29/56(51.8)

0.089

 Abdominal lymph node

16/42(38.1)

15/56(26.8)

0.852

 Distance recurrence

47/89(52.8)

39/95(41.1)

0.335

 Liver

15/47(31.9)

13/39(33.3)

0.696

 Bone

12/47(25.6)

8/39(20.5)

0.360

 Lung

11/47(23.4)

12/39(30.8)

0.830

 Other sites

9/47(19.1)

6/39(15.4)

0.647

 Multiple sites

9/98(9.2)

6/101(5.9)

0.430

Total

98/216(45.4)

101/216(46.7)

0.772

  1. aData are shown as number (%) and continuous data as mean standard deviation or median (interquartile range)
  2. b81 patients in MIILE and 73 patients in Sweet had two or more than two complications
  3. MIILE Minimally invasive Ivor Lewis esophagectomy
  4. RLN Recurrent laryngeal nerves
  5. ARDS Acute respiratory distress syndrome