Skip to main content

Table 3 Categorising communication to patient responses by breast cancer specialists

From: Understanding of BRCA VUS genetic results by breast cancer specialists

 

Total

Medical oncologist

Clinical oncologist

Surgeon

No. (%)

No. (%)

No. (%)

No. (%)

155 (100 %)

63 (40.7 %)

54 (34.8 %)

38 (24.5 %)

Report 1

    

 Appropriate

146 (94.2 %)

62 (98.4 %)

50 (92.6 %)

34 (89.5 %)

 Inappropriate

2 (1.3 %)

1 (1.6 %)a

1 (1.9 %)

0 (0 %)

 Don’t know

7 (4.5 %)

0 (0 %)

3 (5.6 %)

4 (10.5 %)

Report 2

    

 Appropriate

83 (53.5 %)

35 (55.6 %)

28 (51.9 %)

20 (52.6 %)

 Inappropriate

11 (7.1 %)

2 (3.2 %)

3 (5.6 %)

6 (15.8 %)

 Don’t know

61 (39.4 %)b

26 (41.3 %)

23 (42.6 %)

12 (31.6 %)

  1. a‘Other: Probable pathogenic mutation so advice is on assumption that this is pathogenic ....’
  2. bIncludes: Other (n = 3): “These questions are hard to answer when we don't deal with interpreting these reports day to day” (n = 1); “just read about it before seeing patient” (n = 1), “why did I send her for genetic testing?? I wouldn't have done so with no FH!!!” (n = 1)