Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of studies investigating the effects of low-dose BCG

From: Optimal schedule of bacillus calmette-guerin for non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer: a meta-analysis of comparative studies

First author, yr

Design, LOE

No. of Case/Control

Age Case/Control*

Disease category

Follow-up, mo Case/Control*

Strain

Treatment dose (mg) Case/Control

Maintenance** Case/Control

Ojea 2007 [25]

RCT, 1b

139/142

64.9/65.1

Intermediate-Risk NMIBC

61.2/57.3

Connaught

13.5/27

Yes/Yes

Yalcinkaya 1998 [7]

RCT, 1b

25/25

56.3/55.3

Superficial BCa

26.8/31.6

Connaught

54/81

No/No

Kumar 2002 [6]

RCT, 2b

13/13

55.9/56.7

NMIBC without CIS

24(12–30)

Danish 1331

40/120

No/No

Oddens 2013 [28]

RCT, 1b

678/677

68.0/67.0

Intermediate and high risk NMIBC

85.2

OncoTice

27/81

Yes/Yes

Takashi 1995 [27]

R, 2b

37/37

68.1/61.4

Superficial BCa

32

Tokyo 172

40/80

No/No

Yoneyama 2008 [5]

R, 2b

65/85

68.3/65.5

NMIBC without CIS

42.2/90.7

Tokyo 172

40/80

No/No

Irie 2003 [26]

R, 2b

41/39

61.6/62.2

Superficial BCa

27.5/20.0

Tokyo 172

40/80

No/No

  1. LOE Level of evidence, RCT Randomized-controlled trial, R Retrospective, NMIBC Non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer, BCa Bladder cancer, Case/Control, Low-dose/Standard-dose BCG.
  2. * Mean or median.
  3. ** Maintenance is defined as any instillation beyond the induction course.