Diagnostic value of fine-needle aspiration biopsy for breast mass: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Yu, Ying-Hua; Wei, Wei; Liu, Jian-Lun

doi:10.1186/1471-2407-12-41

BMC Cancer

Table 1 Summary of including studies (Insufficient Samples Excluded in test result)

From: Diagnostic value of fine-needle aspiration biopsy for breast mass: a systematic review and meta-analysis

study	year	reference standard	test result				patients (number)	QUADAS score
			TP	FP	FN	TN
Walker et al.[33]	1998	his	91	0	0	19	110	13
Kanchanabat et al.[11]	2000	his/imag and clin	8	8	0	26	42	10
Pisano et al.[12]	2001	his/imag and clin	59	18	17	183	277	11
Lumachi et al.[34]	1999	his	55	0	2	5	62	10
Farshid et al.[35]	2008	his/imag and clin	91	120	2	880	1093	11
Dennison et al.[36]	2003	his/imag and clin	95	0	10	38	143	10
Gent et al.[37]	1986	his	39	7	1	109	156	13
Wanebo et al.[38]	1983	his	123	8	1	102	234	13
Apesteguia et al.[39]	1997	his/imag and clin	2	2	0	107	111	11
Manheimer et al.[40]	1977	his	79	2	11	35	127	11
Janet et al.[41]	2010	his/imag and clin	11	0	4	135	150	9
Drew et al.[42]	1999	his/imag and clin	102	4	27	130	263	8
Masood et al.[43]	1991	his	17	0	3	71	91	8
Ishikawa et al.[44]	2007	his	138	4	4	178	324	12
Harvey et al.[45]	1996	his/imag and clin	14	37	13	32	96	8
Leifland et al.[46]	2003	his	353	11	52	27	443	11
Okamoto et al.[47]	1998	his/imag and clin	5	1	1	125	132	11
Rubin et al.[48]	1997	his/imag and clin	34	4	0	27	65	10
Sauer et al.[32]	2003	his/imag and clin	360	21	47	321	749	11
Li et al.[49]	2008	his	129	1	22	108	260	9
Wang et al.[50]	2010	his	110	2	7	55	174	13
Yang et al.[51]	2010	his	79	0	4	259	342	11
Liu et al.[52]	2000	his	205	1	12	194	412	10
Zhao et al.[53]	2009	his	218	10	6	241	475	11
Zhan et al.[54]	2007	his	32	2	0	44	78	9
Gao et al.[55]	2005	his	169	0	27	85	281	11
Lu et al.[56]	2010	his	102	0	33	48	183	10
Liu et al.[57]	2010	his	5	1	1	125	132	11
Zhang et al.[58]	2008	his	39	6	4	53	102	11
Zhang et al.[59]	2006	his	21	2	3	31	57	9
Tang et al.[60]	1987	his	144	2	13	144	303	11
Wang et al.[61]	1995	his	25	0	2	22	49	10
Ma et al.[62]	2010	his	56	0	2	99	157	8
Wang et al.[63]	2010	his	96	12	4	498	610	8
Wang et al.[64]	1981	his	442	43	60	479	1024	10
Wei et al.[65]	2007	his	91	4	2	78	175	12
Tao et al.[66]	2004	his	655	5	14	2027	2701	12
Wang et al.[67]	2005	his	99	5	0	207	311	11
Chen et al.[68]	2010	his	66	1	9	176	252	8
Zeng et al.[69]	1999	his	94	1	2	66	163	11
Jia et al.[70]	1986	his	49	0	1	50	100	9
Ma et al.[71]	2010	his	68	0	4	291	363	10
Huang et al.[72]	2003	his	305	31	54	436	826	11
Zhang et al.[73]	1996	his	21	1	2	40	64	9
Yu et al.[74]	2006	his	1620	116	33	359	2128	11
Jiang et al.[75]	2008	his	66	1	9	176	252	11

His: histopathology; imag and clin:imaging and clinical follow-up; TP:true positive; FP: false positive; FN:false negative; TN: true negative.

Back to article page

ISSN: 1471-2407

Contact us

Submission enquiries: bmccancer@biomedcentral.com
General enquiries: ORSupport@springernature.com