Skip to main content

Advertisement

Springer Nature is making Coronavirus research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Table 1 Summary of including studies (Insufficient Samples Excluded in test result)

From: Diagnostic value of fine-needle aspiration biopsy for breast mass: a systematic review and meta-analysis

study year reference standard test result patients (number) QUADAS score
    TP FP FN TN   
Walker et al.[33] 1998 his 91 0 0 19 110 13
Kanchanabat et al.[11] 2000 his/imag and clin 8 8 0 26 42 10
Pisano et al.[12] 2001 his/imag and clin 59 18 17 183 277 11
Lumachi et al.[34] 1999 his 55 0 2 5 62 10
Farshid et al.[35] 2008 his/imag and clin 91 120 2 880 1093 11
Dennison et al.[36] 2003 his/imag and clin 95 0 10 38 143 10
Gent et al.[37] 1986 his 39 7 1 109 156 13
Wanebo et al.[38] 1983 his 123 8 1 102 234 13
Apesteguia et al.[39] 1997 his/imag and clin 2 2 0 107 111 11
Manheimer et al.[40] 1977 his 79 2 11 35 127 11
Janet et al.[41] 2010 his/imag and clin 11 0 4 135 150 9
Drew et al.[42] 1999 his/imag and clin 102 4 27 130 263 8
Masood et al.[43] 1991 his 17 0 3 71 91 8
Ishikawa et al.[44] 2007 his 138 4 4 178 324 12
Harvey et al.[45] 1996 his/imag and clin 14 37 13 32 96 8
Leifland et al.[46] 2003 his 353 11 52 27 443 11
Okamoto et al.[47] 1998 his/imag and clin 5 1 1 125 132 11
Rubin et al.[48] 1997 his/imag and clin 34 4 0 27 65 10
Sauer et al.[32] 2003 his/imag and clin 360 21 47 321 749 11
Li et al.[49] 2008 his 129 1 22 108 260 9
Wang et al.[50] 2010 his 110 2 7 55 174 13
Yang et al.[51] 2010 his 79 0 4 259 342 11
Liu et al.[52] 2000 his 205 1 12 194 412 10
Zhao et al.[53] 2009 his 218 10 6 241 475 11
Zhan et al.[54] 2007 his 32 2 0 44 78 9
Gao et al.[55] 2005 his 169 0 27 85 281 11
Lu et al.[56] 2010 his 102 0 33 48 183 10
Liu et al.[57] 2010 his 5 1 1 125 132 11
Zhang et al.[58] 2008 his 39 6 4 53 102 11
Zhang et al.[59] 2006 his 21 2 3 31 57 9
Tang et al.[60] 1987 his 144 2 13 144 303 11
Wang et al.[61] 1995 his 25 0 2 22 49 10
Ma et al.[62] 2010 his 56 0 2 99 157 8
Wang et al.[63] 2010 his 96 12 4 498 610 8
Wang et al.[64] 1981 his 442 43 60 479 1024 10
Wei et al.[65] 2007 his 91 4 2 78 175 12
Tao et al.[66] 2004 his 655 5 14 2027 2701 12
Wang et al.[67] 2005 his 99 5 0 207 311 11
Chen et al.[68] 2010 his 66 1 9 176 252 8
Zeng et al.[69] 1999 his 94 1 2 66 163 11
Jia et al.[70] 1986 his 49 0 1 50 100 9
Ma et al.[71] 2010 his 68 0 4 291 363 10
Huang et al.[72] 2003 his 305 31 54 436 826 11
Zhang et al.[73] 1996 his 21 1 2 40 64 9
Yu et al.[74] 2006 his 1620 116 33 359 2128 11
Jiang et al.[75] 2008 his 66 1 9 176 252 11
  1. His: histopathology; imag and clin:imaging and clinical follow-up; TP:true positive; FP: false positive; FN:false negative; TN: true negative.